Losing Weight Rapidly? Why Fast Fixes, Slimming Soaps and Magnetic Earrings Fall Short

by on February 12th, 2009

It is natural to want results quickly, and the weight-loss market knows it. Shelves and ads are filled with products that promise a slimmer body in days with little effort. Here is why fast fixes rarely last, and how you can tell which claims to ignore.

Why does fast weight loss often come back?

Crash diets and very strict low-carbohydrate or low-calorie plans can cause a quick drop on the scale in the first week or two, but much of it is water, not fat. The water returns as soon as you eat normally again. People also cannot stay on such strict plans forever, so they go back to old eating habits and regain the weight. This is why slower, steadier changes tend to last longer. For more on this pattern, see our post on five warning signs of a fad diet.

How fast is safe?

The CDC says that people who lose weight gradually, about one to two pounds a week, are more likely to keep it off. The NIDDK adds that losing weight very quickly increases the chance of forming gallstones, and that the usual first goal is 5 to 10 percent of your starting weight in six months. Anyone who has a medical condition or wants to lose a lot of weight should talk to their doctor about a plan. If you want quicker progress that is still safe, our article on six tips for faster, safer progress explains how.

Do slimming soaps work?

Some soaps and creams claim to melt body fat through the skin, often with herbs or seaweed in the ingredients. I could not find any research that shows these products reduce body fat. They may cleanse or soften your skin, and that is fine, but fat does not wash away in the shower. The Federal Trade Commission is blunter: in its 2014 “Gut Check” guide for media it says that weight loss is an internal metabolic process, and that nothing you wear or apply to the skin can cause substantial weight loss.

What about magnetic weight-loss earrings?

Magnetic earrings and similar devices claim to curb hunger and speed up metabolism by balancing energy in the body. As with the soaps, I found no study in a medical journal that shows they work, and the FTC’s “Gut Check” guide names earrings, patches, creams, wraps and body belts among the products whose weight-loss claims are false. Wearing one is unlikely to hurt you, but it is probably not a wise way to spend your money. Fashion jewelry is fine as jewelry.

How can you spot a weight-loss scam?

Be careful about promises that sound too good. The NIDDK advises staying away from programs that promise to help you lose weight without diet or exercise, to let you eat as much as you want of your favorite foods, to take off 30 pounds in 30 days, or to lose weight in a specific part of your body. The Federal Trade Commission lists seven claims that experts say cannot be true, including that a product causes weight loss without diet or exercise, blocks the absorption of fat or calories, causes permanent weight loss after you stop using it, or works for every user. Before-and-after photos and personal endorsements can be staged, so treat them with caution. See our post on diet pills for more.

The reliable route is not exciting: smaller portions, more vegetables and fiber, regular exercise and enough sleep, done for months, not days. If you want a plan to follow, start with healthy weight loss in eight habits.

The Side-Angled Stretch (Utthita Parsvakonasana): A Step-by-Step Guide for Desk Workers

by on February 3rd, 2009

After a day at the computer, the sides of your body can feel short and stiff. The side-angled stretch, known in Sanskrit as Utthita Parsvakonasana or extended side angle pose, is a standing yoga posture that lengthens the whole side of the body, from the back foot to the fingertips. This guide explains how to do it step by step, how to make it easier, and what it can and cannot do for you.

How do you do the side-angled stretch?

These instructions follow the standard form of the pose. Take your time and breathe normally throughout. Step 1: stand tall and step your feet wide apart, about three to four feet. Raise your arms to shoulder height with the palms down. Step 2: turn your right foot out to the right by 90 degrees and turn your left foot in slightly. Step 3: exhale and bend your right knee until your thigh is about parallel to the floor, with the knee directly above the ankle and not past it. Keep the left leg straight and press through the outer edge of the left foot. Step 4: lower your right forearm onto your right thigh, or place the right hand on your shin, on a block or on the floor outside your foot. Step 5: reach your left arm up and over your ear so that you form one long line from your left heel to your left hand. Hold for about five slow breaths, then press into your feet to come up and repeat on the other side. If you like, stand with your back near a wall to keep your hips and chest facing the same direction.

How can you make it easier?

Rest your forearm on your thigh instead of reaching to the floor, shorten your stance, or keep the top hand on your hip. Do not worry about how low you go. A pose you can hold comfortably while breathing is worth more than one that strains you. If your balance is not steady, practice next to a wall or a sturdy chair.

What does it do for you?

Stretching keeps muscles flexible, and Harvard Health Publishing says that we need that flexibility to keep a range of motion in our joints. Without it, muscles shorten and become tight, which can make you prone to joint pain and strains. Sitting in a chair all day, for example, tightens the hamstrings. The side-angled stretch works the legs, hips and the muscles along the side of the trunk. The older version of this article claimed that it tones every muscle, cures spondylosis and improves digestion. There is no good evidence for those claims, so I have left them out. Read more in Harvard’s article on the importance of stretching.

How can you stretch safely?

Harvard gives simple rules. Warm up first with five to ten minutes of light activity such as a quick walk, because stretching cold muscles can hurt them. Hold a stretch for about 30 seconds and do not bounce. You should feel tension but not pain, and if you feel pain, stop. Aim to stretch daily, or at least three or four times a week. The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health adds that yoga is generally safe when done properly, that injuries are most often sprains and strains, and that the knee and lower leg are the parts most often hurt. People with a knee or hip injury, lumbar spine disease, balance problems, severe high blood pressure or glaucoma may need to change or avoid some poses, so check with your doctor and a qualified instructor.

What should you try next?

The side-angled stretch is a close relative of the triangle pose, so the two make a good pair. For more postures you can learn at home, see our guide to basic yoga postures and the introduction to yoga postures and styles. If you are new to the practice, what yoga is explains the basics.

Book: Yoga for Computer Users by Sandy Blaine
View this book on Amazon (affiliate link: we may earn a commission at no cost to you)

Buying Vitamins on a Budget: Sales, Bulk Buying and What Not to Skimp On

by on February 1st, 2009

The old version of this post was a guide to finding discount vitamins: watch for sales at your local nutrition store, check the Sunday paper for coupons, and buy in bulk. Some of that is practical, but the post claimed that buying in bulk is “always the best way,” which is not true, and it said nothing about quality or safety. Here is a more balanced guide to saving money without cutting corners.

Do you need to buy vitamins at all?

Possibly not, and that is the cheapest answer. The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements (ODS) says that supplements cannot take the place of the variety of foods that are important to a healthy eating routine, and some people do not need any. Before you spend money, check whether you have a reason: a doctor’s advice, a known deficiency, pregnancy or a restricted diet. Our post on vitamins and your health: do you need a supplement helps you work that out.

How can you find real discounts?

The old post’s tips are fine. Sales at a local store come and go, and the post warned that the sale stock can run out before you get there. Coupons and store flyers are worth checking, and so are online retailers. The key is to compare the price per serving, not per bottle: a large bottle can look cheap and still cost more per dose than a small one. Also compare the amount of the nutrient in each serving, since two products with the same name may contain very different doses. This is general shopping advice and not from a study.

Is buying in bulk a good idea?

Sometimes. A large bottle of a vitamin you take every day can save money. The old post made a sensible warning that you should only buy in bulk if you can use the vitamins before they expire, and that is the main risk. Check the date printed on the bottle, because many products lose strength over time, and store them as the label directs. I could not find an official rule that requires every supplement to carry an expiration date, so if there is no date at all, buy a smaller size. Never buy a large supply of something you have not tried yet. If it upsets your stomach, you will have wasted the money.

Is the cheapest product good enough?

This is the real question. ODS explains that the FDA does not determine whether supplements are effective before they are marketed, and that quality seals from independent groups, including ConsumerLab.com and NSF International, show that a product was properly manufactured, contains the ingredients listed on the label and does not contain harmful levels of contaminants. The seals do not guarantee that a product is safe or effective, but they are a useful check. A product with an independent seal that costs a little more can be a better value than a cheaper product with no checks. The post on choosing a vitamin supplement explains how to read labels.

Which deals should you avoid?

Be careful with very large doses sold as bargains. The upper limits exist for a reason. According to ODS, the tolerable upper intake level for vitamin C is 2,000 mg a day for adults, and for supplemental vitamin E it is 1,000 mg a day. Too much preformed vitamin A from supplements can cause severe headache, blurred vision and nausea, and in pregnancy it can cause birth defects. A bigger bottle does not mean you should take more. The old post also said that millions of Americans take vitamins daily and that this makes them a sound investment. Popularity is not proof of benefit. NCCIH notes that strong evidence for many supplement claims is lacking.

How do you get the most for your money?

Buy only what you need, take it as directed, and put the savings into food. Fresh and frozen fruit and vegetables, beans, whole grains and nuts give you vitamins, minerals and fiber at a low cost per serving. If you take a daily multivitamin, a store brand with an independent quality seal can be a sensible choice. Read about how and when to take supplements so that you get the most from each dose, and ask your doctor or pharmacist whether your medicines interact with anything you plan to buy. You can read the full ODS consumer guide here: Dietary Supplements: What You Need To Know.

Yoga Explained: What It Is, Who Practices It and What the Research Supports

by on January 23rd, 2009

Say “yoga” and many people picture a cross-legged figure on a mountaintop, or someone twisted into an impossible pose. The reality is much more ordinary. Most people who practice yoga today do so in a class or at home, and they do it to feel better. Here is what yoga involves, who does it and what science says.

What is yoga?

According to the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, yoga is an ancient and complex practice rooted in Indian philosophy. Although classical yoga includes other elements, yoga as practiced in the United States typically emphasizes physical postures (asanas), breathing techniques (pranayama) and meditation (dhyana). You do not have to be flexible to start. Styles range from slow and gentle to athletic, which we describe in yoga postures: an introduction to asanas and styles and in what is yoga?.

How common is it?

Very. A national survey found that the share of U.S. adults who practiced yoga rose from 5.0 percent in 2002 to 15.8 percent in 2022. In 2012 survey data, 94 percent of adults who practiced yoga did so for wellness-related reasons, and 17.5 percent did it to treat a specific health condition. Some did both.

What does research say about the benefits?

The honest answer is: some benefits, small to moderate, and not for everything. Research suggests that yoga may help improve general wellness by relieving stress and improving mental and emotional health, sleep and balance. For low-back pain, a 2022 review of 21 studies found yoga slightly better than no exercise, although the small difference may not matter to patients. For depression, yoga can be a helpful addition to treatment, not a replacement. In a 2019 study of 227 people, those in a yoga group were 37 percent more likely to have quit smoking by the end of the 8-week program, but 6 months later there was no difference between the groups. Yoga should not be seen as a cure for any disease.

Can yoga help you lose weight?

There is some evidence that it can help. The NCCIH reports that a 2022 review of 22 studies with 1,178 participants who had overweight or obesity showed reductions in body weight, BMI, body fat and waist size, and that a 2013 review of 17 yoga-based weight-control programs found that most led to gradual, moderate weight loss. The programs with the best results had longer and more frequent sessions, at least 75 to 90 minutes and at least 3 times a week, and ran for 3 months or more. So yoga can be one part of a weight plan, together with food choices and other activity.

Is yoga safe?

It is generally considered safe for healthy people when performed properly, under the guidance of a qualified instructor. Injuries can occur, as in any physical activity. The most common are sprains and strains, and the knee or lower leg is the part of the body most often injured; serious injuries are rare. If you are new to yoga, avoid extreme practices such as headstands, shoulder stands, the lotus position and forceful breathing, and be aware that hot yoga has special risks related to overheating and dehydration. Learning yoga on your own without supervision has been associated with increased risks. Pregnant women, older adults and people with health conditions should talk to their health care provider and the instructor first.

How should you start?

Pick a beginner class or a good video for beginners, tell the teacher about any injuries and go at your own pace. Our guide to basic yoga postures and their variations covers simple poses, and how to start yoga safely explains what to know if you have diabetes. Read the NCCIH overview of yoga’s effectiveness and safety for the full details.

Eating Low-Carb on a Budget: Practical Ways to Cut Costs Without Dropping the Plan

by on January 20th, 2009

Low-carb eating can be expensive when it leans on fresh meat, specialty products and recipes with long ingredient lists. It does not have to be. A few habits will lower the cost of a week of meals without changing what you eat. Here are the ones that work best.

Why does planning save money?

Recipes in diet books often call for pricey ingredients because they are meant to look impressive. You can follow a low-carb plan with simple meals such as eggs and vegetables, a roast chicken with salad, or a stir-fry made from what is in the freezer. Plan the week’s menu, write a shopping list and go after you have eaten, because shopping when you are hungry usually adds to the bill. If you are following a specific plan, our posts on planning for Atkins and Atkins diet basics explain what to include.

Is buying in bulk and freezing safe?

Yes, when you do it properly. The USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service says that food kept constantly at 0 °F stays safe, and that recommended storage times are for quality only. Uncooked ground meat keeps its best quality for 3 to 4 months and cooked meat for 2 to 3 months. Divide large packs into meal-sized portions in freezer bags, label them with the date, and thaw them in the refrigerator, in cold water or in the microwave, never on the counter. Freeze leftovers within 3 to 4 days. See the USDA guidance on freezing food.

Which protein foods are the best value?

Look beyond steak. Cuts that are often cheaper, such as chicken thighs, and cuts that cook well in a slow cooker, can give you protein for less. Eggs are a bargain: USDA data show that 100 grams of hard-boiled egg has about 12.6 grams of protein and about 1 gram of carbohydrate, and roasted chicken thigh meat has about 24.8 grams of protein and no carbohydrate. Tofu is another option. Keep an eye on legumes, which are inexpensive but contain carbohydrate: boiled lentils have about 19.5 grams per 100 grams and canned kidney beans about 21.5 grams, so they may only fit in small amounts, depending on the stage of your plan.

Can you save on vegetables?

Buy whole heads of lettuce rather than bagged salad, since you pay for the washing and chopping with bagged salad. Romaine has only about 3 grams of carbohydrate per 100 grams. Frozen vegetables are convenient and cheap, and the USDA notes that the freezing process itself does not destroy nutrients. Cauliflower, broccoli and spinach are good choices. A salad spinner keeps leaves crisp, so that less is thrown away.

Are low-carb products worth buying?

Usually not. Low-carb bars, breads and snacks tend to cost more than ordinary foods, and the label can hide extra carbohydrate. They also often use sweeteners, and the World Health Organization advises against relying on non-sugar sweeteners for weight control. Spend your money on real food instead. If you want to try a swap, cauliflower rice and zucchini noodles are simple and cheap. Check the nutrition facts panel, and look up foods in the USDA FoodData Central database when you are not sure.

What else helps?

Use sales: if chicken thighs are cheaper than breasts this week, swap them in, as long as the recipe stays within your plan. Cook once and eat twice, for example by roasting a large tray of vegetables and chicken. Keep a food list in your phone so that you can check an unfamiliar sale item. And remember that diets for weight loss work best when you can keep them up for a long time; a plan that you can afford is one you can follow. Our post on common mistakes Atkins dieters make lists the pitfalls to avoid.