Archive for the ‘Weight Loss’ Category

Popular Diet Plans Compared: What Each One Asks of You

by on Wednesday, May 6th, 2009

Anyone who has tried to lose weight has met them: a long shelf of diet books, each with testimonials and a bold promise. Some people choose a plan because they want a better body, others because they are unhappy with their health, and others simply to stay fit. With so much publicity, it is easy to feel confused about which one to follow. Here is a short, neutral summary of ten well-known plans, followed by what research says about them.

What do the low-carbohydrate and low-fat plans ask you to do?

Atkins: A low-carbohydrate plan, which starts with a very strict first phase of about 20 grams of net carbohydrates a day. You eat meat, eggs, cheese and low-starch vegetables and avoid bread, pasta and sugar. Critics point out that it can be low in fiber and high in saturated fat unless you choose carefully. See our posts on the basics of the Atkins diet and overcoming plateaus on Atkins.

The Carbohydrate Addict’s Diet: Based on the idea that some people crave carbohydrates. You eat two low-carbohydrate meals each day and one balanced “reward meal” that includes carbohydrate foods.

Choose to Lose: Uses a daily “fat budget” and encourages low-fat foods, with vegetables, fruit and grains on the menu. Because it is low in fat, it is generally considered a healthy approach.

What about the balanced and group plans?

DASH: Short for Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension. It was designed to lower blood pressure and is rich in vegetables, fruit, whole grains and low-fat dairy and low in sodium. It is a well-researched, balanced pattern, though it was not designed as a weight loss plan.

Eat More, Weigh Less (Dr. Dean Ornish): A vegetarian plan that is very low in fat and high in fiber, with nonfat dairy and egg whites allowed. It is rich in whole plant foods, so it suits vegetarians, but it can be hard to follow, and if you leave out dairy and eggs altogether you need a reliable source of vitamin B12.

The Pritikin Principle: A low-fat, high-fiber plan focused on unrefined whole grains, vegetables, fruit and legumes, with limited lean animal protein.

Volumetrics: Created by nutrition researcher Barbara Rolls, it focuses on foods that are low in calorie density, such as soup, vegetables and fruit, which fill you up for fewer calories. It is considered a sensible, flexible approach.

The Zone: A plan that sets out meals with about 40% of calories from carbohydrates, 30% from protein and 30% from fat. It is rich in vegetables and fruit, but it takes careful measuring.

Weight Watchers: A group program that assigns foods a point value and lets members plan their own meals. Its main feature is the support and accountability of regular meetings.

Is there a plan to be wary of?

Eat Right for Your Type: This plan assigns foods to you according to your blood type. We do not recommend it, because a 2013 systematic review found no evidence that it improves health.

Which one is best?

There may not be a winner. A 2014 analysis of 48 randomized trials, published in JAMA, found that people on low-carbohydrate and low-fat named diets lost significant weight, and that the differences between the individual diets were small. The authors concluded that any diet that a person will stick to is a reasonable choice. For most people, then, the question is not “Which plan is best?” but “Which one can I follow for years?”

What should you check before you start?

Check the basics before you start: a plan should include a variety of foods, give you enough nutrients and not make claims that sound too good to be true. Talk to your doctor if you have a medical condition. Our posts on a healthy diet for weight loss and the weight loss plan to aim for can help you take the next step.

What to Know About Diet Pills: Types, Safety and Who Should Avoid Them

by on Thursday, April 23rd, 2009

What there is to know about diet pills

Diet pills come in many forms and with many different ingredients. One thing is certain: never use them as a substitute for cutting calories without your doctor’s advice. If you and your doctor decide that a diet pill is right for you, a few simple steps make it safer.

How should you take diet pills safely?

Take the pill whole with a full glass of water, as the label says, and do not dissolve it in drinks or soup. Some diet pills have a diuretic effect, which makes you urinate more often and can lead to dehydration. Drink plenty of water through the day to protect yourself.

Take only the recommended dose. Taking more than the label says will not make you lose weight faster, and it raises the risk of side effects. Follow the instructions given by your doctor, dietitian or pharmacist and do not rely only on what is printed on the box. Remember, too, that a pill can only support a diet plan. It does not replace one.

Pay attention to your heart. If you notice a racing or pounding heartbeat, chest pain, dizziness or fainting, stop taking the pill and call your doctor. A resting heart rate above 100 beats per minute is considered fast.

Finally, ask how long you should take the pill. Products are not meant to be used indefinitely. With prescription weight loss medicines, the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases says your doctor will probably advise stopping if you have not lost at least 5% of your starting weight after 12 weeks on the full dose.

What are the two kinds of diet pills?

Prescription diet pills are drugs regulated by the US Food and Drug Administration. Their side effects are monitored, and they are prescribed in set doses. One of the best known is orlistat, sold as Xenical, which is approved for long-term use. It reduces the amount of fat your body absorbs, and its side effects include diarrhea and oily or sudden bowel movements, which is why users are advised to follow a low-fat diet.

Over-the-counter products are a mixed group. A lower-dose form of orlistat, called Alli, is sold without a prescription and is FDA-approved. Most other over-the-counter diet pills, however, are dietary supplements, and supplements do not need FDA approval before they are sold. Some have been found to contain hidden drugs, and some have caused serious harm. In 2000 the FDA asked manufacturers to stop selling products that contained phenylpropanolamine, a stimulant that was once common in diet pills, after it was linked to a higher risk of stroke.

Does natural mean safe?

No. Not everything that comes from a plant is harmless. A classic example is ma huang, the herb that is a source of ephedrine, a strong stimulant. Supplements containing ephedrine alkaloids were banned in the United States in 2004 because of safety concerns. Always check the ingredients, and ask a pharmacist about anything labeled “natural” or “herbal”.

Who should avoid diet pills?

Check with a doctor first if you have, or have had, prostate problems, thyroid disease, a serious mental illness, high blood pressure or heart problems. The same applies to anyone who has had seizures or a stroke. Do not take diet pills together with cold medicines, especially those with decongestants, unless a pharmacist has said it is safe. Stimulant-type diet pills can cause chest pain, anxiety, trouble sleeping and low mood.

As a general rule, do not use diet pills if you are pregnant or think you might be, and if you are sensitive to sulfites or the food coloring tartrazine, check the label. Anyone under 18 or over 60 should talk to a doctor before taking any product for weight loss, especially one based on stimulants that is meant to replace exercise.

What is a better plan?

Most people do better with changes they can keep up. To see what is in many of these products, read our post on what is in a weight loss diet pill. For prescription options, see our post on tablets to help with weight loss. Our weight loss tips and our post on natural weight loss explain how to make progress with food and movement.

Your First Week: A Simple Walking and Strength Plan to Start Losing Weight

by on Thursday, March 12th, 2009

Many weight-loss plans fail on day one because they start too hard. A better way to begin is with a gentle first week that builds the habit of moving and teaches you what your body can do. Here is a simple sample week for a beginner. It is a starter plan based on general exercise guidelines, not a program that will melt fat in seven days, and no one-week plan can do that.

What should you do before you start?

See your doctor for a check-up before starting a weight-loss program, particularly if you have been inactive, are over 40 or have a health condition such as heart disease, diabetes or joint problems. Wear comfortable shoes and keep water nearby. Be patient: it took time to gain weight, and it will take time to lose it. The NIDDK suggests an initial goal of 5 to 10 percent of your starting weight within six months.

What does a sample week look like?

Day 1: Walk at an easy pace for 20 minutes, then do a few minutes of gentle stretching. You should be able to talk while you walk.

Day 2: Walk for 10 minutes to warm up, then do a short strength routine with your own body weight: 8 to 10 sit-to-stand moves from a chair, 8 wall push-ups and 8 lunges holding on to a counter. Rest between sets.

Day 3: Walk briskly or alternate one minute of faster walking, or light jogging if you are comfortable, with two minutes of easy walking for about 10 to 15 minutes. Finish with stretches.

Day 4: Rest day. Do some gentle stretching or a slow walk around the block. Rest is part of the plan, because muscles adapt during recovery.

Day 5: Two 10-minute walks, one in the morning and one in the evening, with your lower-body strength moves from Day 2 in between.

Day 6: Choose something low-impact that you enjoy, such as swimming, cycling or a gentle yoga class. Variety helps you stay interested. Our guide to basic yoga postures has gentle ideas.

Day 7: Take a longer walk with a friend or family member. Support makes it easier to keep going. Add a few light upper-body moves afterward, such as wall push-ups or arm raises with water bottles.

How do you build on it?

The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans recommend at least 150 minutes of moderate-intensity activity a week for adults, plus muscle-strengthening activities on two or more days. This first week adds up to less than that on purpose. Increase your total by about 5 to 10 minutes a week until you reach the target. Keep a simple log, because seeing your progress in writing is motivating. Read more about making exercise part of weight loss and everyday activities that count as moderate exercise.

What if you miss a day?

Carry on with the next one. One skipped session does not undo a week. Weight loss happens through steady habits, such as moving most days and eating a little less, not through one perfect week. If your plan makes you feel dizzy, causes chest pain or leaves you in pain that does not ease, stop and call your doctor. When you are ready for the next step, our weight-loss plan guide shows how to set goals that you can keep.

Losing Weight Rapidly? Why Fast Fixes, Slimming Soaps and Magnetic Earrings Fall Short

by on Thursday, February 12th, 2009

It is natural to want results quickly, and the weight-loss market knows it. Shelves and ads are filled with products that promise a slimmer body in days with little effort. Here is why fast fixes rarely last, and how you can tell which claims to ignore.

Why does fast weight loss often come back?

Crash diets and very strict low-carbohydrate or low-calorie plans can cause a quick drop on the scale in the first week or two, but much of it is water, not fat. The water returns as soon as you eat normally again. People also cannot stay on such strict plans forever, so they go back to old eating habits and regain the weight. This is why slower, steadier changes tend to last longer. For more on this pattern, see our post on five warning signs of a fad diet.

How fast is safe?

The CDC says that people who lose weight gradually, about one to two pounds a week, are more likely to keep it off. The NIDDK adds that losing weight very quickly increases the chance of forming gallstones, and that the usual first goal is 5 to 10 percent of your starting weight in six months. Anyone who has a medical condition or wants to lose a lot of weight should talk to their doctor about a plan. If you want quicker progress that is still safe, our article on six tips for faster, safer progress explains how.

Do slimming soaps work?

Some soaps and creams claim to melt body fat through the skin, often with herbs or seaweed in the ingredients. I could not find any research that shows these products reduce body fat. They may cleanse or soften your skin, and that is fine, but fat does not wash away in the shower. The Federal Trade Commission is blunter: in its 2014 “Gut Check” guide for media it says that weight loss is an internal metabolic process, and that nothing you wear or apply to the skin can cause substantial weight loss.

What about magnetic weight-loss earrings?

Magnetic earrings and similar devices claim to curb hunger and speed up metabolism by balancing energy in the body. As with the soaps, I found no study in a medical journal that shows they work, and the FTC’s “Gut Check” guide names earrings, patches, creams, wraps and body belts among the products whose weight-loss claims are false. Wearing one is unlikely to hurt you, but it is probably not a wise way to spend your money. Fashion jewelry is fine as jewelry.

How can you spot a weight-loss scam?

Be careful about promises that sound too good. The NIDDK advises staying away from programs that promise to help you lose weight without diet or exercise, to let you eat as much as you want of your favorite foods, to take off 30 pounds in 30 days, or to lose weight in a specific part of your body. The Federal Trade Commission lists seven claims that experts say cannot be true, including that a product causes weight loss without diet or exercise, blocks the absorption of fat or calories, causes permanent weight loss after you stop using it, or works for every user. Before-and-after photos and personal endorsements can be staged, so treat them with caution. See our post on diet pills for more.

The reliable route is not exciting: smaller portions, more vegetables and fiber, regular exercise and enough sleep, done for months, not days. If you want a plan to follow, start with healthy weight loss in eight habits.

Why Losing Extra Weight Helps Your Health: What the Research Shows

by on Friday, January 2nd, 2009

Losing weight is hard, so it helps to know what is in it for you. The reasons go well beyond looking different. Carrying extra weight raises the risk of several serious conditions, and for many people even a modest loss makes a measurable difference. Here are the main benefits, with what the research says and what it does not.

Does it help your heart and blood pressure?

Yes, it is likely to. The National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases explains that having overweight or obesity raises your risk of high blood pressure, high cholesterol and high blood sugar, all of which can lead to heart disease. Losing weight may help lower your blood pressure and other risk factors for stroke. Weight is only one of the factors involved, so keep an eye on your cholesterol numbers as well. Our post on what you can do to lower your cholesterol gives practical steps.

Does it help with type 2 diabetes?

It does. Nearly 9 in 10 people with type 2 diabetes have overweight or obesity. For people at risk of developing the condition, the NIDDK says that losing at least 5 to 7 percent of starting weight may prevent or delay it. For a 200-pound person that is about 10 to 14 pounds. If you already have diabetes, regular activity and weight loss can improve blood sugar control. Do not change your diabetes medicine on your own, though. Ask your doctor, because doses may need to be adjusted as your weight falls.

What about cancer?

The National Cancer Institute says that people with overweight or obesity are at greater risk for at least 13 types of cancer, including cancers of the endometrium (the lining of the uterus), colon and rectum, kidney, and the breast after menopause. That does not mean that every person who is heavier will get cancer, and it is less clear how far weight loss lowers that risk. Studies on this are harder to interpret, since people who lose weight differ in other ways from those who do not. Still, avoiding weight gain and staying active are sound choices.

Can it ease sleep apnea and joint pain?

Often, yes. Sleep apnea is a condition in which your upper airway becomes blocked and you stop breathing for short periods while you sleep, which is why people snore loudly and feel sleepy in the daytime. The NIDDK says that losing weight may help reduce sleep apnea or make it go away. Extra weight also puts pressure on the knees, hips and lower back, and losing weight may decrease that stress and lessen inflammation in the body, which can help osteoarthritis. A small loss may even ease fatty liver; the NIDDK notes that losing at least 3 to 5 percent of your body weight may reduce fat in the liver.

How much do you need to lose?

Less than most people think. Experts recommend an initial goal of 5 to 10 percent of your starting weight within six months. That is about 10 to 20 pounds for someone who weighs 200 pounds, and it is enough to bring health benefits. Aim for slow, steady loss, and talk to your doctor before you start, especially if you have a health condition. Rapid loss has its own risks, such as gallstones. For practical advice, take a look at eight habits that work for losing weight and how to fit exercise into weight loss. If a plan makes big promises, check it against our list of warning signs of a fad diet.