Yoga as Exercise: What a Class Gives You and Why You Still Need Cardio

by on June 23rd, 2010

The old version of this post made yoga sound like the perfect kind of exercise: calming, energizing and nearly free from injury. Parts of that are fair, but the text also claimed that yoga does not need to be supplemented. In fact it said the opposite further down, that you should still do regular aerobic exercise. This rewrite sorts out what yoga does well as exercise and what it does not.

Is yoga really exercise?

Yes, though how much it counts depends on the style. The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans list active forms of yoga, such as vinyasa or power yoga, as moderate-intensity activity. They describe hatha yoga as more meditative, and they include some forms of yoga among muscle-strengthening activities. A slow class that mostly involves breathing and gentle stretching still has value, but it may not raise your heart rate enough to count as aerobic exercise. Check with the teacher about how active the class will be.

Why do people feel calm and energized afterward?

The old post said students feel tranquil after class and still have more energy. Many people report that. A likely reason is the mix of slow movement, attention to breathing and a final rest, which together may bring on what the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health calls the relaxation response: slower breathing, lower blood pressure and a lower heart rate. I could not find a study that proves the post’s claim that yoga gives you more energy than other exercise, so treat it as a common experience, not a research result.

What makes it a balanced workout?

A well-planned class works both sides of the body, and the old post described it nicely: you bend to the right and then to the left, forward and then back. That helps you notice if one side is stronger or more flexible than the other, and over time you can work toward more even strength and movement. The post also said that you hold a pose for several seconds or even minutes, with attention on slow, full breaths. Slow and steady movement into and out of postures is the key to doing them safely.

Is it safe, and can everyone do it?

NCCIH says yoga is generally safe when it is done properly under the guidance of a qualified instructor, and that the injuries reported are mostly sprains and strains. The old post said the chance of injury is small when poses are done correctly, and that you should never compete with yourself or others, which is good advice. People of all ages can practice, and a skilled teacher can adapt most postures with chairs, cushions or a wall. If a pose looks impossible in a picture, do not worry, because a modified version may be right for you. NCCIH also says that some conditions, such as lumbar spine disease, severe high blood pressure, glaucoma, balance problems and some injuries, may need changes to certain poses. Pregnant women and older adults should talk to a health care provider first. Our guide to preparing for yoga with a warm-up is a good start.

Why do you still need aerobic exercise?

Because the guidelines ask for more than yoga usually provides. The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans advise adults to get at least 150 to 300 minutes of moderate-intensity aerobic activity each week, such as brisk walking or fast dancing, plus muscle-strengthening activity on at least two days. The old post agreed with the aerobic part, noting that aerobic exercise increases cardiovascular fitness and helps you lose weight. It also made a claim about blood sugar control in type 2 diabetes. I could not verify that detail in the sources I checked, so if you have diabetes, ask your own doctor how much and what kind of exercise suits you.

How can you combine them?

A simple plan is to do two or three yoga sessions a week for flexibility, balance and relaxation, and to add brisk walking, cycling or swimming on other days. Our post on moderate exercise for fitness offers easy ways to start with cardio, and everyday activities that count as moderate exercise shows how daily tasks add up. If you want a simple yoga routine to start with, try the basic yoga postures and their variations. Combining the two covers strength, stamina, flexibility and a calm mind, which is a more complete picture than yoga alone.

Buying Home Fitness Equipment: Seven Checks Before You Pay

by on June 23rd, 2010

A treadmill, a rowing machine or a set of resistance bands can make it easier to exercise at home. But fitness equipment is also sold with big promises, and it is easy to spend money on something that ends up in the corner of a room. This guide lists seven checks to make before you buy, and starts with the advertising claims that cannot be true.

Can a machine really melt fat?

No machine can do that on its own. The U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) puts it bluntly: if a product promises weight loss without effort and sacrifice, it is bogus. Its “Gut Check” guide to claims that cannot be true is written for supplements, over-the-counter drugs and products worn on the body or rubbed on the skin, and says it does not cover exercise equipment, but the main points carry over. Meaningful weight loss requires taking in fewer calories than you use, and even for the most effective products, weight loss of more than a pound a week over a long period is unusual. So if an ad promises that you will lose several pounds in a week or drop a size in a month, treat it as a warning sign. Read the FTC guide to spotting false weight loss claims.

Can it burn fat from one body area?

This is another claim to be wary of. Machines and gadgets are often sold as a way to get rid of fat from the belly, hips or thighs. A 2022 review and meta-analysis in the journal Human Movement combined 13 studies with 1,158 participants and found no spot reduction: training one part of the body had no effect on the fat stored in that area. Exercise helps your overall fitness and, together with what you eat, helps you lose fat across the whole body. You cannot choose where it comes off. You can read the study abstract at the journal Human Movement.

Do before-and-after photos prove anything?

They show one person’s result, not what will happen to you. The FTC says that advertisers who use testimonials must either show results that are typical of what other consumers can expect, or clearly disclose what the typical results are. Pictures also rarely say what else the person did, such as changing their diet, so treat testimonials as advertising.

What should you read in the small print?

Read the fine print, because it often says that the results depend on following a calorie-controlled diet as well as using the machine. Check these points before you pay (they are general shopping advice, not rules from a study): the full price including shipping, handling, tax, delivery and assembly fees; the monthly payment and the length of any financing, since a low monthly price can add up to far more than the machine is worth; the length of the warranty and what it covers; the return policy, including who pays for return shipping on a heavy item, since that can cost more than you expect to get back; and how to reach customer service, ideally a number that is answered by a person.

Will you actually use it?

The best machine is the one you use. Think about what you enjoy, how much space you have and whether you would be happier in a class. If you have a health condition or have not exercised for a long time, check with your doctor before starting. The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans advise adults to get at least 150 to 300 minutes of moderate-intensity aerobic activity each week, and that can come from a walk outdoors, which is free. Our posts on how to choose a gym, group fitness classes and health and fitness describe other ways to be active, and everyday activities that count as moderate exercise shows how much you can do with no equipment at all.

What is a sensible plan?

Set a realistic goal and combine movement with healthy eating. NIDDK says experts recommend an initial weight-loss goal of 5 to 10 percent of your starting weight within six months. Be careful of promises of overnight results: our posts on overnight weight loss and losing weight rapidly explain why quick fixes do not last. If you decide to buy, pick a reputable seller, keep your receipt, and put the machine where you will see it every day.

Eating to Lower Cholesterol: A Diet Plan Built on Fiber, Plants and Healthier Fats

by on June 1st, 2010

The old version of this post was called “The Best Low Cholesterol Diet Plan,” and it made several large claims: that eating vegetables and soy can be just as effective as medicine, that a vegetarian diet can cut cholesterol by a third in a month, and that a plan followed “religiously” can lower it by 29 percent. Some of those numbers come from a real study, but they describe a tightly controlled trial and not what most people see at home. Here is a more careful version of the same advice, with the targets that official health agencies use.

Why does diet matter for cholesterol?

High LDL (“bad”) cholesterol raises the risk of heart disease and stroke, as our post on what cholesterol is and why too much is a problem explains. The National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute says that the Therapeutic Lifestyle Changes (TLC) and DASH eating plans can help you lower LDL. They encourage limiting saturated fats from fatty cuts of meat, dairy products and desserts, eating whole grains, fruits and vegetables instead of refined carbohydrates, eating a variety of nuts and preparing foods with little or no salt.

What are the numbers to aim for?

MedlinePlus describes the TLC diet like this: no more than 25 to 35 percent of your daily calories should come from fat, and less than 7 percent of your calories should come from saturated fat. It also advises less than 200 mg of dietary cholesterol a day for people trying to lower their cholesterol, and 10 to 25 grams of soluble fiber a day. The old post’s “reduce saturated fat by seven percent” was a garbled version of that 7 percent limit. For everyone else, the Dietary Guidelines for Americans say less than 10 percent of calories from saturated fat and less than 2,300 mg of sodium a day. The old post gave 2,400 mg, an older figure, so I replaced it.

Which foods help most?

The old post’s food list holds up: oatmeal and oat bran, fruit, beans, nuts, soy foods and vegetables. MedlinePlus lists oatmeal and oat bran, apples, bananas, oranges, pears, prunes and legumes as high in soluble fiber, which helps prevent your digestive tract from absorbing cholesterol. For fats, it suggests swapping saturated fat for lean meat, nuts and unsaturated oils such as canola, olive and safflower. Our post on eating to lower cholesterol with oats, fruit, beans and healthy fats has practical ideas.

Can food work as well as medicine?

For some people it can come close, but not for everyone, and this is where the old post went too far. The study behind the “29 percent” figure was by Jenkins and colleagues and was published in JAMA in 2003. It followed 46 adults with high cholesterol for four weeks. Those on a “portfolio” diet of plant sterols, soy protein, viscous fiber and almonds, low in saturated fat, saw their LDL drop by 28.6 percent, compared with 30.9 percent in those taking the statin lovastatin and 8.0 percent in those on a low-fat control diet. That is a real result, but it came from a strict plan over four weeks, and most people find that hard to keep up. The old claim that a vegetarian diet cuts cholesterol by one-third in a month is not supported by this study, so I removed it. If your doctor has prescribed a statin, keep taking it and use food as an addition. See our post on what statins do.

What might a day of eating look like?

The old post gave a sample day: soymilk and oat bran cereal with chopped fruit and almonds, oatmeal bread and jam for breakfast, bean soup with soy cold cuts and fruit for lunch, and a vegetable and tofu stir-fry for dinner. That is a reasonable pattern. A few cautions: check labels for sodium and trans fat, because processed soy deli slices, margarine and canned bean soup vary a lot (this is general label-reading advice, not a figure from a study).

What else should you do?

Food is only part of it. Regular physical activity also belongs in the plan; see exercise and cholesterol. NHLBI also recommends getting your cholesterol checked and talking with your health care provider about treatment, which may include medicine. For the official guidance, read How to lower cholesterol with diet on MedlinePlus and the NHLBI page on treatment.

What Is Hatha Yoga? A Look at the Most Popular Style and a Typical Class

by on May 31st, 2010

Walk into almost any gym or yoga studio in the United States and the class on offer will be some form of hatha yoga. The old version of this post said so, but the text was too garbled to follow. Here is a clear guide to the branches of yoga, what “hatha” means in practice, and what happens in a typical class.

What are the branches of yoga?

Yoga is traditionally described as having several paths. Bhakti yoga is the yoga of devotion, jnana yoga is the yoga of knowledge, and karma yoga is the yoga of selfless action. Hatha yoga is the branch that works with the body through postures and breathing. In the United States, as the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health puts it, yoga typically emphasizes physical postures (asanas), breathing techniques (pranayama) and meditation. That is why most people meet hatha yoga first.

Is hatha yoga a single style?

Not really. Harvard Health describes hatha as a combination of many styles and says it is one of the most popular. The old post listed examples ranging from exercise-intense power yoga to the gentle chair poses used in Svaroopa yoga. Because the word covers so much, two classes both called “hatha” can feel very different. NCCIH notes that yoga styles range from gentle practices to physically demanding ones, and the 2018 U.S. Physical Activity Guidelines distinguish between more meditative hatha yoga and active forms such as vinyasa or power yoga.

What happens in a typical class?

Harvard Health gives a simple outline: a hatha class usually begins with pranayama, controlled breathing exercises, then moves through a series of asanas, or postures, and ends with savasana, a resting period. The old post described a one-hour class that started with a group breath or a shared “om,” included a quick series of movements and a long stretch, and finished with about 20 minutes of lying down. That structure is common, though the exact timing varies by teacher. Many studios have no mirrors, so students can focus on what they feel rather than how a pose looks.

What does that final rest feel like?

The old text described students in the closing relaxation: some going through to-do lists in their heads, some asleep, and some in a very calm, aware state. All of these are normal. The final rest is not a test, and you cannot do it wrong. If you find it hard to lie still, our post on before you start yoga: warm-up, breathing and listening to your body offers simple ways to ease into it.

Does hatha yoga count as exercise?

It can, but it depends on the class. The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans list active forms of yoga, such as vinyasa or power yoga, as moderate-intensity activity. They describe hatha yoga as more meditative and note that some forms of yoga can count toward muscle-strengthening. A slow, restful class is valuable for stress and flexibility but may not give you the 150 to 300 minutes of moderate aerobic activity that adults are advised to get each week, so many people combine it with walking or other cardio.

The old post also said that yoga builds flexibility, strength, stamina and better circulation. Flexibility and strength are reasonable to expect from a regular practice, but I could not find good evidence for the claim about circulation, so I have left it out. Another claim, that integral yoga is “not religious,” is a matter of the individual studio. Ask the teacher what the class includes before you go.

How do you choose a class?

Start with the label “beginner” or “gentle hatha,” and look for a teacher who explains each pose and offers alternatives. Avoid extreme poses such as headstands in your first weeks, as NCCIH advises. Our guide to the basic postures and their variations shows what to expect in your first few classes, and what yoga is covers the background.

Yoga, Tai Chi and Qigong: Gentle Mind-Body Practices for a Stressful Life

by on May 31st, 2010

Many people who start yoga say it feels different from the gym. One woman quoted in the original version of this post described aerobics classes and exercise machines as a torture chamber and yoga as a welcome change. That old article also described yoga as part of a wider “mind-body” movement that includes tai chi and qigong. This rewrite follows that idea and checks what the research says about all three.

What are mind-body practices?

The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health calls yoga, tai chi and qigong “meditative movement” practices. All three combine physical movement with meditative elements such as attention to breathing. In the United States, yoga typically emphasizes physical postures (asanas), breathing techniques (pranayama) and meditation. Tai chi and qigong come from China and use slow, flowing movements. NCCIH describes qigong breathing as slow, long and deep.

Does yoga help with stress?

There is reasonable evidence that it can. NCCIH reports that a 2020 review of 12 studies, with 672 healthy adults in total, found that yoga had beneficial effects on perceived stress in every one of the studies. It also says that some, but not all, studies of yoga for stress have shown improvements, so yoga is not a guaranteed cure for a stressful life. The practice may help most as a regular pause in the day, a few minutes to breathe slowly and notice your body. For ideas on how to build one in, see our post on a gentle morning routine for beginners.

What about tai chi and qigong?

Tai chi has the stronger research record of the two, though not mainly for stress. According to NCCIH, a 2019 review found low-certainty evidence that tai chi may reduce the rate of falls in older people by 19 percent (based on 7 studies with 2,655 participants). A 2021 review of 16 studies with 986 participants found low-to-moderate evidence that it helps knee osteoarthritis, improving pain and stiffness. The research on qigong is smaller: for conditions such as fibromyalgia, NCCIH describes it as initial research based on only a few small studies. Neither practice has been shown to cure anything, and the NCCIH pages I checked do not give a stress review for tai chi or qigong that compares with the one for yoga.

Are they safe?

Generally, yes. NCCIH says tai chi appears to be safe: a 2019 review of 24 studies with 1,794 participants found that the frequency of adverse events was similar for people doing tai chi, another active intervention or no intervention. For yoga, most injuries reported are sprains and strains, and the risk is lower when a qualified instructor teaches the class and you avoid extreme poses as a beginner. If you are pregnant or have a health condition, check with your health care provider first.

Is it really cheap and easy?

Partly. The old post called yoga a cheap, easy-to-start exercise for busy and stressed people, and for the most part that holds. You can begin with a mat and a few minutes at home. Props can be improvised: according to Cleveland Clinic, a rolled-up towel can replace a blanket and a necktie or T-shirt can replace a strap. Still, classes cost money, and NCCIH cites a small 2021 survey in which cost was the most common barrier to yoga among low-income Hispanic adults. Free videos can help, and our guide on how to pick a yoga video that works for you explains what to look for.

The old post also noted that stressed people still need the motivation to become physically fit, and that is true. A mind-body practice will help you only if you actually do it. Start with something short and gentle, choose the style that you enjoy, and give it a few weeks. Our introduction to basic yoga postures and their variations is a good place to begin if you prefer yoga to the other two.