Herbal Weight Loss: What Herbal Options Can and Cannot Do

by on January 18th, 2011

Losing weight? Go herbal

These days there is a lot of interest in losing weight. Being lighter can lead to a healthier lifestyle and makes everyday movement easier. The choices are huge: exercise programs, machines, supplements, diet drinks, pills and even soaps that claim to help you lose weight while you bathe.

One alternative that many people consider is to go herbal. Herbal products are often seen as a gentler, more natural way to lose weight. Their effects tend to be subtler, so results, if any, come slowly. Natural does not automatically mean safe or effective, though, so here is what to know.

Are herbal weight loss products safe?

Many of them are sold as dietary supplements, and in the United States supplements do not need approval before they are sold. You can find a lot of herbal pills and teas on the Internet and in shops. Some claim to be safe because they are herbal, but some have side effects, and many have not been studied properly. The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements concludes that the evidence that weight loss supplements work is inconclusive and unconvincing. Here are some ingredients to be careful with.

Senna is an herbal laxative found in many slimming teas. It works by stimulating the colon, and the downside is that it can cause cramps, diarrhea and dehydration. A laxative makes you lose water and stool, not body fat, and regular use may make some people dependent on it. See our post on the dangers of using laxatives for weight loss.

Chromium picolinate is a form of chromium, a mineral that helps regulate blood sugar. Studies of chromium for weight loss found only a minimal effect on body weight and body fat. Side effects can include headache, watery stools and nausea.

St. John’s wort is a herb used for low mood, not a weight loss herb. It can interact with many medicines, including birth control pills, blood thinners and antidepressants, and it can make skin more sensitive to sunlight, so never take it without checking with a doctor or pharmacist.

Does organic food help you lose weight?

Organic food is grown without most synthetic pesticides, and many people buy it for that reason or for the environment. There is no good evidence that organic food in itself makes you lose weight. An organic cookie has about as many calories as any other cookie. What helps is eating more vegetables, fruit and whole foods, whether they are organic or not.

What about green tea and caffeine?

Green tea is the best-studied herbal option. Clinical trials suggest that it may have a modest effect on body weight, and as a drink it has not raised safety concerns, although it contains caffeine. Green tea extracts are another matter: they have been linked to stomach upset, higher blood pressure and, in some people, liver damage. Claims that green tea speeds up fat burning by 40 percent or makes you lose two to three times more weight do not hold up.

Caffeine does give a small boost. In one study, a 100 mg dose, about a cup of coffee, increased energy expenditure by about 9 calories an hour for three hours. That is a very small amount and no substitute for exercise.

Are other herbs worth trying?

Gynostemma pentaphyllum, known as jiaogulan or “immortality herb”, is a traditional Chinese herbal tea. It has been promoted for many things, but I found no strong evidence that it helps with weight loss.

Apple cider vinegar is another popular choice. One 12-week study in Japan found that obese adults who took one or two tablespoons of vinegar a day lost a small amount of weight, a few pounds, more than people who took a placebo. That is a modest result from a single study. Vinegar should always be diluted, because drinking it undiluted can harm tooth enamel and irritate the throat, and it is not a proven treatment for any disease.

What is the best approach?

There is no herbal shortcut. Look into the ingredients and the evidence before you buy anything. Ask a doctor or pharmacist whether a product is safe for you, especially if you take medicines or have a health condition. To see what the labels of diet products really mean, read our posts on what is in a weight loss diet pill and what to know about diet pills. For lasting results, our weight loss tips and our post on natural weight loss explain how to make steady progress with food and movement.

Vitamin C Skin Care: The Challenge

by on July 7th, 2010

Vitamin C skin care: the challenge

Vitamin C is widely regarded as a skin protector and an anti-aging agent. In technical terms, the main aim of Vitamin C skin care is to support the production of collagen (a structural protein found in skin). A further benefit of Vitamin C skin care is its ability to counter free radicals, which damage the skin.

Vitamin C skin care, however, faces a real challenge: Vitamin C is unstable. On contact with an oxidising agent (e.g. air or light), the Vitamin C in a skin care product oxidises, which makes the product much less effective. Oxidised Vitamin C turns the product a yellowish-brown colour. Check for this before buying a Vitamin C skin care product. After you buy one, store it properly and keep checking that it is still good to use (i.e. that it has not turned yellowish-brown).

Manufacturers have tried to deal with this oxidation problem in various ways, and research on Vitamin C skin care products is high on their list. One way of keeping the products effective for longer is to use a high concentration of Vitamin C. However, this makes the products more expensive, and they are already fairly expensive. Another way is to use Vitamin C derivatives (like ascorbyl palmitate and magnesium ascorbyl phosphate). These are more stable and cheaper. There is less evidence that the derivatives work as well as pure Vitamin C, but their stability is a very attractive feature. They are also known to be less irritating.

Talking of the effects of Vitamin C skin care products, it is important to note that not everyone responds to Vitamin C treatments. So it is not a magic potion in any way. If you do not see a noticeable difference in your skin, it may be because your skin does not respond to Vitamin C (and the product may not be at fault at all).

As research goes on, we can only keep our fingers crossed and wait for a complete solution to the challenges faced by Vitamin C skin care today.

Calcium Supplements: How to Take Them Safely

by on July 5th, 2010

Supplements for calcium

Your body needs calcium throughout your life. At certain times, such as childhood, breast-feeding and pregnancy, getting enough is especially important. Children need calcium for growing teeth and bones, and adults need it to keep their bones strong and to lower the risk of osteoporosis. Calcium also plays a part in normal blood clotting and in muscle and nerve function.

How to take calcium supplements

If you take calcium supplements, take them with or just after a meal and drink a large glass of liquid, preferably water. If you use chewable tablets, chew them thoroughly before you swallow. If chewing is hard for you, let the tablet dissolve in a glass of water or juice and drink it slowly. Calcium can interfere with some medicines, so ask your pharmacist how long to wait between your supplement and your other medication.

Calcium supplements can help your bones and teeth, but you should make sure they are right for you before you buy them. Talk to your doctor first if you have kidney stones, kidney disease, stomach problems or diarrhea. If you are pregnant or breast-feeding, let your doctor know that you are interested in or taking calcium supplements.

Side effects and limits

Most people can take calcium supplements, but too much can cause problems. High doses may lead to constipation, nausea, vomiting, a dry mouth and a loss of appetite, and over the long term they can raise the risk of kidney stones. For most adults the upper limit from food and supplements together is 2,500 mg a day (2,000 mg after age 50). If you notice any of these problems, contact your doctor.

When you see your doctor, mention any other medicines you take and any history of illness in your family. Side effects are rare, but they do happen and may mean that some people should not take these supplements.

Food comes first, though. Adults usually need about 1,000 to 1,200 mg of calcium a day, and good sources include dairy products, fortified plant milks, tofu made with calcium, kale, bok choy and almonds. Supplements are only meant to fill the gap if your diet falls short. You can buy them in pharmacies, supermarkets and online. They are not expensive, and your doctor can tell you whether you need one and how much.

The Rewards of Regular Activity and Where Yoga Fits In

by on June 27th, 2010

The old version of this post was a press-style announcement for a yoga teacher’s website and TV series. It said that as we enter a new millennium, more people are looking for lifestyle changes that bring mental and spiritual well-being as well as physical fitness, and that yoga is enjoying a renaissance. Underneath the marketing is a sound point: gentle, regular activity is good for you. Here is what the research on activity shows and where yoga fits in.

Why does regular physical activity matter?

The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans summarize the evidence. In their second edition, they say that activity has immediate benefits: it can reduce anxiety and blood pressure and improve sleep quality and insulin sensitivity. For adults, regular activity helps prevent eight types of cancer (bladder, breast, colon, endometrium, esophagus, kidney, stomach and lung). It also lowers the risk of dementia, heart disease, stroke, high blood pressure, type 2 diabetes and depression, and improves bone health, physical function and quality of life. The old post made a similar point, adding that exercise does not have to be strenuous to work. That is also correct: the guidelines say that any amount of physical activity has some health benefits.

How much do adults need?

At least 150 to 300 minutes a week of moderate-intensity aerobic activity, such as brisk walking or fast dancing, according to the guidelines. They also recommend muscle-strengthening activity, like lifting weights or doing push-ups, on at least two days each week. The first guideline for adults is to move more and sit less. These are targets to work toward, and anyone who is just starting out can begin with less.

Where does yoga fit?

Yoga can be one part of the plan. The guidelines note that yoga comes in many forms and that active forms, such as vinyasa or power yoga, count as moderate-intensity activity, while more meditative hatha yoga may not. Some forms of yoga also count toward muscle strengthening. The old post said yoga offers “the perfect combination of strength and flexibility.” That sounds too strong, since yoga does not replace aerobic exercise, but it does train both strength and flexibility, and many people enjoy it enough to keep doing it. Enjoyment matters, because the best activity is the one you will actually do. For a fuller picture of what the research supports, read what yoga is and what the research supports.

Is yoga really 5,000 years old?

The old post said yoga’s roots go back about 5,000 years, and that the Sanskrit word means “union.” The first part is hard to prove. The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health calls yoga an ancient and complex practice rooted in Indian philosophy that began as a spiritual practice. Scholars disagree about its early history, and the oldest surviving textbook on it, the Yoga Sutras, is dated by various scholars between about the 2nd century BCE and the 5th century CE. So “ancient” is accurate, but the exact age is uncertain. The meaning “union” is the commonly given translation of the word, and it is widely used in yoga teaching.

Can you learn yoga online?

The original post celebrated bringing yoga to a wide audience through the internet, television and DVDs. Many people do learn that way, and it is a good option if classes are too costly or too far away. A video cannot see your form, though, and NCCIH advises beginners to avoid extreme practices and to be careful with hot yoga and forceful breathing. Our guide to learning yoga online explains how to pick a teacher or website, and the post on choosing a yoga video for beginners covers what to look for in a video.

What should you take away?

Aim for regular, enjoyable activity, mixing aerobic exercise, strength work and something that improves flexibility and calm. Yoga can fill the last two roles. Start slowly, listen to your body, and talk to a health care provider if you have a medical condition before changing your routine. For more ideas on getting moving, read health and fitness: why exercise matters and how to start.

24 Hour Fitness: Club Tiers, Memberships and Questions to Ask Before You Join

by on June 26th, 2010

The old version of this post called 24 Hour Fitness the Walmart of the fitness world, said it had around three hundred clubs open around the clock, and promised there was no long-term contract. The company has changed a great deal since that was written, so this rewrite keeps the useful idea (a big chain can be a one-stop gym) and replaces the details with what the company says today. Check the current facts for your own club before you sign anything.

How big is 24 Hour Fitness now?

Smaller than it was. A June 2020 bankruptcy filing, made when the company entered Chapter 11, said that as of March 31, 2020 it served about 3.4 million members at 445 locations. According to its own membership page, it now offers access to over 235 clubs at the top tier, and an August 2026 trade-press report put the total at roughly 240 clubs in nine states, most of them in California. So the old figure of more than three hundred clubs is out of date, and you should look at a map before assuming there is one near you.

What do the club tiers and membership levels mean?

The company currently lists three club tiers: Sport, Super-Sport and Ultra-Sport. The higher the tier you pay for, the more clubs you can use, and Ultra-Sport covers every location. It also lists three membership levels, called GetFit, KeepFit and KeepFit+. According to the company, GetFit covers the basics (cardio, weights and functional training areas) at your home club only, KeepFit adds classes, pools, saunas and courts where a club has them, and KeepFit+ adds recovery rooms and extras such as body scans. The old post described four club types with amenities such as heated pools, whirlpools, steam rooms and spa services. The company says that exact amenities vary from location to location, so use its club finder to check the specific club you have in mind rather than relying on a tier name.

Is every club open 24 hours?

No. The company says that “many” of its gyms are open 24 hours, which is not the same as all of them. The old post said every club was open around the clock. If late-night or early-morning access is the reason you are considering this chain, check the posted hours for your own club.

Is there really no contract?

I could not confirm that. The old post said you could pay monthly and that there was no long-term contract, but the company’s page says that each member’s access and benefits are governed by the terms of their individual membership agreement. That is a reason to read the agreement. The Federal Trade Commission’s advice on free trials and auto-renewals is a useful checklist: find the terms, know how and when you can cancel, put the cancellation date in your calendar, and watch your card statements. If a company keeps charging you after you cancel, the FTC suggests disputing the charge with your card issuer.

What about personal training and a nutrition plan?

The old post described a sports-performance program, a resistance-training program and a metabolic rate test at the end of a workout. I could not verify that any of these are offered today, so ask the club exactly what is included in a trainer package and what costs extra. A sensible plan, wherever you train, matches national guidelines: adults should aim for 150 to 300 minutes of moderate aerobic activity a week plus muscle-strengthening activities on two or more days. Our guide to group fitness classes and how to stay consistent explains how to fit classes around that.

Do you need vitamins to go with a gym plan?

The old post said that vitamins and supplements are a necessity unless you are sure you get enough iron, calcium and vitamins C, D and E. That goes too far. The NIH says, for example, that most people in the United States get enough iron, and that most get enough vitamin B12 from the foods they eat, although some groups (women under 50 and pregnant women for iron, older adults for B12) are more likely to fall short, and some supplements carry risks. Our post on vitamins and your health explains who may benefit. A better use of your time is a plan you will follow: read moderate exercise for fitness for easy ways to get started if you are not sure what to do first in a large gym.