Archive for the ‘vegetarian health’ Category

Detox Foot Patches: What They Claim and What the Evidence Says

by on Sunday, October 25th, 2009

Detox foot patches: what they claim and what the evidence says

Today there are many pollutants and chemicals that can enter your body by different routes. Detox foot patches are sold with the promise of drawing these substances out of your body while you sleep. This post looks at what the patches claim and what is actually known about them.

Sellers say that waste products build up in the body because of environmental factors, such as pollutants in the air and things in the food we eat, and that a foot patch is the way to remove them. In reality, your liver, kidneys, lungs, gut and skin already remove waste from your body around the clock.

How the patches are used

A detox foot patch is a small pad that you stick to the sole of your foot and leave in place overnight. The idea is that it gives waste products an outlet through the skin of the foot.

The pads usually contain simple ingredients such as wood or bamboo vinegar and plant extracts. Sellers claim they pull toxins out of the body and so relieve stress, fatigue and other health problems. Foot patches are popular in parts of Asia and are sold worldwide, but popularity is not proof that they work.

What the evidence says

Here is how the advertised advantages hold up.

Claim: the patches treat the symptoms of many different ailments by removing large amounts of toxins. There is no good scientific evidence for this. The dark colour on a used pad appears when the ingredients get damp, and pads have been shown to darken from sweat or plain water alone, without any toxins.

Claim: users feel relaxed and cleansed. Some people do say they sleep better or feel more relaxed, but there are no reliable studies showing that the patches clean the body or improve overall health.

Claim: easy to use while you sleep or work. The patches are easy to use, but that does not make them effective.

Claim: a non-invasive, mess-free treatment. It is true that there are no creams or liquids, but the patches are not a recognised medical treatment. In the United States, the Federal Trade Commission took action against marketers of one foot patch brand in 2009 over unsupported health claims.

Claim: affordable. Any price is too much for a product with no proven benefit. If you have ongoing fatigue, stress or other symptoms, see a doctor instead, because they can have causes that need treatment.

In summary, a detox foot patch may feel like a pleasant bedtime ritual, but there is no good evidence that it removes toxins or improves health. Your own organs do that job. If you are thinking of trying the patches, treat any results with caution and talk to your doctor about symptoms that worry you.

Balancing pH and Detox to Cleanse the Body

by on Tuesday, September 15th, 2009

Balancing pH and detox to cleanse the body

Grow, glow and go. These are the three food groups that a person should eat every day, in the right amounts, to have a healthy and nutritious diet. This is the subject of one of the many science lessons in elementary school that teach children about eating a healthy, balanced diet.

From the very start, people have been used to eating all kinds of food products, as well as beverages, and without knowing it, we also take in small amounts of unwanted chemicals with them. The body has its own ways of removing unwanted toxins, mainly through the liver and kidneys, and in healthy people it does this very effectively.

Different fluids are found inside the human body, and the cells are sensitive to their pH level. The pH level is the measure of how acidic or alkaline something is. The body has its own very precise way of managing pH: the lungs and kidneys keep the pH of the blood within a narrow range (about 7.35 to 7.45). If they cannot do this properly, the imbalance affects the whole body.

Some detox programs claim that stress, tiredness, unwanted weight, fatigue, aches, pains, poor digestion and other disorders are signs that your body is too acidic. In fact, these symptoms have many possible causes. Truly acidic blood (acidosis) is a medical condition, usually caused by illnesses such as kidney disease or uncontrolled diabetes, and it needs a doctor rather than a detox.

Detox writers name three things that are supposed to make the body more acidic: taking in acids, producing acids, and not getting rid of acids properly.

Foods such as meat, dairy, processed sugar, alcohol and coffee are often called acid-forming. They can make your urine more acidic, but they do not change the pH of your blood, which your body keeps steady.

Some detox advocates also claim that yeasts and harmful bacteria thrive in an acidic body and produce even more toxins. There is no good evidence for this, and such claims should be treated with caution.

Some acids are strong, while others are weak. The body buffers acids with several systems, including the bicarbonate in your blood, your breathing and your kidneys. Acid builds up in the body only when these systems are not working properly, for example because of illness.

Your liver and kidneys do the actual work of detoxification. You can support them by not overloading them, especially with alcohol, and by seeing a doctor if you suspect they are not working well.

For a healthy body, you need good food and nutrition. Rather than relying on special products, eat a diet rich in vegetables and fruit, get proper nutrition and keep your body well hydrated. This supports the body’s own detox process.

Alkalizing products are also sold in stores with the promise of balancing your pH. Your body already keeps its pH balanced, so there is little reason to buy them. If you are worried about acid build-up, the right step is a check-up with your doctor.

A detox program can be a good way to start eating better, with more vegetables and fewer processed foods, but it is the change in diet that helps, not the detox itself.

Good health does not come overnight; it comes through self-discipline and determination. Changing simple things in your daily routine will benefit you and your body more than any quick fix.

Remember, your body keeps its own pH in balance. If you have symptoms that worry you, such as ongoing tiredness, pain or digestive problems, that is the right time to consult your doctor.

Slimming Teas and Laxatives for Weight Loss: Why They Do Not Work and What the Risks Are

by on Sunday, September 6th, 2009

Slimming teas, dieter’s teas and other “cleansing” products are sold in many stores, and they often seem natural and gentle. But most of them work in one way only: they are laxatives. Using laxatives to lose weight does not remove fat, and it can do real harm. This post explains why.

What is in slimming tea?

Many of these teas contain plant ingredients that are laxatives, such as senna, aloe, cascara, rhubarb root and buckthorn, and sometimes castor oil. They have been used for centuries to treat constipation. They are not tea in the usual sense, and the label may describe them as a “natural bowel cleanse” or a “detox” and avoid the word laxative. The calories in the cup are close to zero unless the tea is sweetened, so any effect on the scale comes from the laxative. In 2002 the FDA ruled that aloe and cascara sagrada could no longer be sold as ingredients of non-prescription laxative products in the United States, because the safety data the agency asked for had not been submitted.

Do laxatives make you lose fat?

No. The food you eat is digested and absorbed mostly in the small intestine, and laxatives act on the large intestine afterward. In a small 1983 study of seven women, two with bulimia who used laxatives for weight control and five healthy young women, researchers measured calorie absorption and found that even extreme purging, which produced 4 to 6 liters of diarrhea, cut the calories absorbed by only about 12 percent of intake. You can read the study abstract on PubMed. The lower number on the scale after a laxative is mostly water and it returns when you drink, which is why the National Eating Disorders Association calls the idea that laxatives control weight a myth.

What are the risks?

Repeated use can cause dehydration, an imbalance of the body’s minerals such as potassium and sodium, stomach cramps, nausea and fainting. A mineral imbalance can affect the heart and muscles. The body can also come to depend on laxatives, so that the bowel stops responding to normal doses and constipation gets worse. The National Eating Disorders Association lists severe dehydration, electrolyte disturbances, laxative dependence and damage to internal organs among the consequences of misuse. Women who are pregnant or trying to conceive should not take laxatives or herbal laxative teas without asking their doctor.

Who should be especially careful?

Laxative misuse is common among people who have, or are at risk of, an eating disorder. If you find that you are using laxatives to “make up” for eating, or you feel anxious when you cannot, please talk to a doctor or a mental health professional. Treatment works, and you do not have to manage it alone. Anyone who uses laxatives regularly for constipation should also see a doctor to find out why.

What works instead?

If you want to lose weight, the safest approach is a slow one: reduce portions a little, eat more vegetables, beans and whole grains, move more, and sleep enough. For constipation, fiber, fluids and exercise are better first steps than a laxative tea. For more on products that promise quick fixes, see our posts on diet pills and who should avoid them, herbal weight loss and eight habits for losing weight the healthy way. If a product promises easy weight loss with no effort, it is wise to leave it on the shelf.

Healthy Eating Recipes Often Sold as “Detox”: Soups, Juice and Ginger Tea, Without the Cleanse Claims

by on Friday, September 4th, 2009

The old version of this post presented a set of recipes as detox recipes, said they would “cleanse your body from toxins,” and recommended a three-day fast followed by a diet of one kind of fruit at each meal. The recipes themselves are simple vegetable-heavy dishes and they are fine as ordinary healthy meals. The claim that they cleanse your body is not supported, and the fasting plan is not something I can recommend. Here is how to enjoy the recipes and what to know first.

Do detox recipes remove toxins?

No good evidence says so. The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health says that a 2015 review concluded there was no compelling research to support the use of “detox” diets for weight management or for eliminating toxins from the body and that a 2017 review found that juicing and “detox” diets can cause initial weight loss but tend to lead to weight gain when normal eating resumes. Your liver and kidneys already remove waste, as our post on what your body already does to clean itself explains. The recipes below are worth making because they are vegetables, not because they purify anything. See also body detox the easy way.

What about the fast and the one-fruit diet?

The old post quoted a Dr. Kiki Sidhwa as recommending a three-day fast followed by a diet of one type of fruit at each meal: apple for breakfast, oranges or pineapple for lunch, and apples, pears, grapes or bananas in the evening. I could not verify this advice or the doctor’s credentials, and a diet of one food at a time is low in protein and many nutrients. NCCIH lists fasting and eating only certain foods among the “detox” approaches it reviewed, and notes that there have been no studies on the long-term effects of such programs. Anyone with a medical condition or on medication should ask a doctor before fasting.

How do you make the vegetable juice and the soups?

I have kept the ingredients of the old post’s recipes. Quantities were garbled, so treat them as a guide.

Green vegetable juice: one whole cucumber, four celery sticks, two to four handfuls of spinach and eight lettuce leaves, with parsley if you like. Juice the vegetables and add water and a little lemon juice. Whole vegetables keep the fiber that juicing removes. The old post suggested adding alfalfa sprouts. The FDA advises avoiding raw sprouts of any kind, including alfalfa, because bacteria can reach high levels during sprouting even under clean conditions, and recommends cooking them thoroughly, so I would leave them out or cook them.

Raw avocado soup: blend one avocado with 100 ml of light vegetable stock into a paste, then blend in two spring onions, a pepper, a cucumber, two handfuls of spinach, a garlic clove and the juice of a lemon or lime. The old post called it “alkalising,” a claim with no support, so I dropped the word. It also added Bragg Liquid Aminos for flavor. That is a soy-based seasoning that adds salt, so use it sparingly if you watch your sodium.

Warm broccoli soup: lightly steam six to eight broccoli heads for five to six minutes, then blend them with an avocado, a third of an onion, a celery stick, a large handful of spinach, a piece of fresh ginger and cumin, and season with garlic and pepper.

Is the ginger and turmeric tea worth drinking?

As a warm drink, yes. The old recipe used two cups of water, a teaspoon each of powdered ginger and turmeric, a tablespoon of maple syrup and some lemon, simmered for ten minutes and strained. It will not cleanse you. NCCIH says that for turmeric, there is not enough evidence to conclude that it is beneficial for any health condition, though it is widely used in cooking. If you take medicines or are thinking of using turmeric as a concentrated supplement, ask your doctor first, as supplements are much stronger than the spice in a tea.

What should you do instead?

Make the soups part of a normal week of vegetables, fruit, beans, nuts and whole grains. The old post’s rule of thumb, more fiber and water, is good advice. If you buy juice, choose pasteurized products, because the FDA warns that unpasteurized juice can contain harmful bacteria that make children, the elderly and people with weakened immune systems seriously ill. For the full evidence, read NCCIH’s page on detoxes and cleanses, and see our guide to gentle detox habits versus harsh cleanses.

What Is in a Weight Loss Diet Pill? Common Ingredients and the Evidence

by on Tuesday, August 18th, 2009

What is in a weight loss diet pill?

Exercise and dieting take effort, so it is no surprise that many people are tempted by an easier way. The advertisements for diet pills promise that their products will melt fat away without much work, and the market is huge. According to the National Institutes of Health, more than two-thirds of adults in the United States are overweight or have obesity.

The big questions are whether these pills really work, whether they help you keep weight off, and what is actually inside them.

Do diet pills really work?

The honest answer is: barely, if at all. The NIH Office of Dietary Supplements reviewed the common ingredients and concluded that the evidence that weight loss supplements work is inconclusive and unconvincing, and that the products can be costly. Even where there is an effect, it tends to be small, and phrases such as “clinically proven” on a label should not be taken at face value.

What ingredients are common?

Labels are full of unfamiliar names. Here are the groups mentioned most often in marketing, and what is known about them.

Ingredients said to boost metabolism include green tea extract, L-carnitine and alpha-lipoic acid. Green tea may have a modest effect on body weight, but green tea extract has been linked to liver problems in some people. An analysis of nine trials found that people who took carnitine lost, on average, about 1.3 kilograms (about 3 pounds) more than those who took a placebo. Research on the other ingredients is limited.

Ingredients meant to curb your appetite include fibers such as glucomannan and guar gum, which swell in the gut so that you feel full. In studies they had little or no effect on body weight, and glucomannan has raised safety concerns. Caffeine and other stimulants can reduce hunger a little, but they can also make you jittery and raise your heart rate.

Ingredients called calorie or carbohydrate blockers include white kidney bean extract (Phaseolus vulgaris), which interferes with an enzyme called alpha-amylase that breaks down starch. It may have a modest effect on weight. Chitosan, made from shellfish shells, is said to bind fat. In one study, the fat it trapped would add up to a loss of only one pound of body fat in about seven months, and people with a shellfish allergy could react to it.

Some products advertise “lipotropic” ingredients such as vitamin C, chitosan, alpha-lipoic acid and hops extract that supposedly sweep fat out of the body. That is a marketing word, and I found no good evidence that these ingredients do so.

Finally, some pills contain diuretics. These make you lose water, not fat, and they can cause dehydration.

Why is “clinically proven” a warning sign?

Supplements are not approved by the FDA before they are sold, and the manufacturer decides what the label says. Some weight loss supplements have turned out to contain hidden prescription drugs. If a label promises quick, easy loss, be skeptical. Check the claim against a source such as the NIH fact sheets rather than the seller’s website.

What is a better approach?

No pill replaces a healthy way of eating and regular activity. If you want help, talk to a doctor about safe options. Our guide to what to know about diet pills covers how to use them more safely and who should avoid them, and our post on whether weight loss tablets are safe lists questions to ask. For approved medicines, see our post on tablets to help with weight loss. And for everyday habits that work, read our weight loss tips.