Archive for the ‘Atkins’ Category

Atkins Diet Pros and Cons: What the Research Supports and Where the Claims Go Too Far

by on Thursday, June 30th, 2011

The Atkins diet is one of the best-known low-carbohydrate plans, and the old version of this post listed its benefits and its few downsides. It also said that low-carb eating has been “scientifically proven” to improve insulin sensitivity, blood pressure and blood insulin, and that dieters lose less muscle than on low-fat plans. I could not support those claims, so this rewrite goes back to the studies.

What are the possible benefits?

A 2013 meta-analysis in the British Journal of Nutrition looked at 13 trials with 1,415 people who followed a very-low-carbohydrate diet or a low-fat diet for at least a year. The low-carb group lost about 0.9 kg (2 pounds) more on average, had lower triglycerides, a slightly lower diastolic blood pressure and higher HDL (“good”) cholesterol, but also higher LDL (“bad”) cholesterol. The authors described the differences as statistically significant but small in practical terms. A larger 12-month trial of 609 adults found no significant difference between a healthy low-carb and a healthy low-fat diet (6.0 kg lost compared with 5.3 kg), which fits the common advice that the best plan is usually the one you can keep following. See the meta-analysis abstract for the details.

Is it really “eat what you like”?

The old post argued that steak, butter and cream are a regular part of the plan, and that former dieters would enjoy the “forbidden” foods. That freedom is part of the appeal, but it is also the part doctors worry about. Harvard Health notes that these diets often look like plates piled with bacon, meat, eggs and cheese, and that the American Heart Association recommends about 13 grams of saturated fat a day (6 percent of a 2,000-calorie diet). A 20-week trial that fed people high-saturated-fat low-carb diets did not show worse heart-risk markers, but it was short, and how such diets affect heart attacks or strokes in the long run is unknown. Vegetables, nuts, fish and olive oil make a safer base than processed meat.

What are the downsides?

The first two weeks are the hardest. Cleveland Clinic says that “keto flu” symptoms (headache, fatigue, irritability, nausea, constipation or diarrhea) can appear two to seven days after you reach ketosis and last between two days and a month, usually somewhere in between. The old post said these effects are “transient” but that some people quit because of them, which is fair. Harvard Health adds that a strict ketogenic diet can raise LDL cholesterol, and that using it for a long time is linked to a higher risk of kidney stones, osteoporosis and gout. Low-fiber eating can also cause constipation, so keep non-starchy vegetables on the plate.

What about carb counting and your personal carb level?

The old post said some people can maintain weight on 90 grams of carbohydrate a day and others on 120. Atkins now says that most people’s personal carb tolerance is 40 to 120 grams of net carbs a day, and that you find yours in the later phases. Atkins has also renamed its plans, so the names of the phases may differ from the old ones. Our post on Atkins Diet basics explains the structure, and Atkins induction rules walks through the first two weeks.

Who should talk to a doctor first?

If you are pregnant or breastfeeding, have kidney disease or a history of disordered eating, or take medicine for diabetes, speak with your doctor before you start. The American Diabetes Association’s standards say that low-carb plans are not recommended for pregnant or lactating women, people with or at risk of disordered eating, or people with kidney disease, and that they should be used with caution with some diabetes medicines called SGLT2 inhibitors. Our guide to common mistakes Atkins dieters make helps you avoid the usual traps. Finally, the old post said “it works” for thousands of dieters, which is true for short-term weight loss, but the research shows that the long-term difference is small.

Atkins Diet Foods: What You Can Eat, What to Check on the Label and How to Plan

by on Sunday, March 27th, 2011

Atkins is a low-carbohydrate way of eating, and the foods you choose depend on which phase you are in. The old version of this post gave a muddled description of the “Atkins pyramid” and told readers to rely on the diet’s own products. This updated guide sticks to what Atkins itself publishes, and adds what independent sources say about labels and balance.

What does an Atkins plate look like?

The Atkins company describes the plan in terms of net carbohydrates, which it defines as total carbohydrate grams minus fiber grams, and in its low-carb foods also minus sugar alcohols. Protein foods such as meat, poultry, fish and eggs, together with fats such as olive oil and butter, are the base of each meal. Carbohydrates come mainly from what Atkins calls “foundation vegetables,” which are non-starchy vegetables such as leafy greens, asparagus, peppers, celery, cucumbers and cruciferous vegetables like broccoli and cauliflower. Avocados and olives count too. Root vegetables such as potatoes, sweet potatoes, parsnips, carrots and beets are not foundation vegetables. You can see the list on the Atkins healthcare professionals page on foundation vegetables.

Which foods are limited at the start?

In the first phase, Induction, Atkins allows 20 grams of net carbohydrates a day, with 12 to 15 grams coming from foundation vegetables. It asks people to avoid sugar, white flour and other refined grains, whole grains, most fruit (other than avocado, tomatoes and olives), legumes, starchy vegetables and milk. Berries and other foods are added back in later phases. The old post said that fruits are used sparingly in the early stages and whole grains only occasionally, which is in line with this. Our post on Atkins diet basics explains the four phases, and the Induction rules are covered in a separate post on the first two weeks.

Can you rely on low-carb labels?

Not blindly. The old post warned that manufacturers put “low carb” on labels to sell products, and that is a fair concern. The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center notes that neither the FDA nor the American Diabetes Association endorses the idea of “net carbs” and that they advise people to look at total carbs on the nutrition label. Even so, it can be useful to know net carbs if you have diabetes or are trying to lose weight. A good habit is to read the Nutrition Facts label and the ingredient list, check the serving size, and subtract fiber from total carbohydrate yourself. See the OSU article on tracking net carbs.

How can you plan meals and shop?

Write a list of acceptable foods and keep it with you, so that you are not trying to remember what you can eat when you are hungry. Plan meals for the week and shop from a list. The old post suggested using Atkins cookbooks and online menu planners, many of which are written by companies selling food, so judge them as you would any diet advice. Our posts on planning meals for Atkins, low-carb swaps and eating low-carb on a budget give practical ideas.

Is it a balanced way to eat?

That depends on how you do it. Plenty of non-starchy vegetables, fish, eggs and nuts can be part of a healthy diet, but a plan built on processed meat, butter and packaged low-carb bars may not be. Talk to your doctor or a dietitian before starting, especially if you have diabetes, kidney disease or take medicine for blood pressure or cholesterol. The Atkins site itself says that the weight loss phases should not be used by people on dialysis and that you should consult a doctor before beginning.

View this book on Amazon (affiliate link: we may earn a commission at no cost to you)

Low-Carb Swaps for the Atkins Diet: Cauliflower Rice, Zucchini Noodles and a Word on Sweeteners

by on Thursday, February 25th, 2010

The hardest part of cutting carbohydrates is rarely the meat or the eggs. It is giving up bread, pasta, rice and potatoes, the foods that sit at the center of so many meals. A swap can make the change feel smaller, and some of them work well. Here is what to try, with the carbohydrate numbers checked against USDA data, and a caution about the sweeteners that often come along with low-carb baking.

Which vegetables can replace pasta?

Zucchini and spaghetti squash are the favorites. According to USDA FoodData Central, 100 grams of raw zucchini has about 3 grams of carbohydrate and cooked spaghetti squash about 6.5 grams, compared with about 31 grams in 100 grams of cooked enriched pasta. Cut zucchini into ribbons or thin strips with a peeler or spiralizer and cook them briefly, because they release water. Roast spaghetti squash and pull the strands out with a fork. The sauce is usually what people like most about pasta, so a meat sauce, pesto or a cheese and vegetable topping goes over either one.

What can stand in for rice and potatoes?

Cauliflower is the classic. A raw 100-gram portion has about 5 grams of carbohydrate, against about 28 grams in cooked white rice and 21 grams in a baked potato. To make “rice,” chop florets in a food processor until they are the size of rice grains and microwave them without water for a few minutes. For a “mash,” steam the florets and puree them until smooth with a little butter or cream cheese. Mashed home-prepared potato has about 17 grams per 100 grams, and the cauliflower version is lower, though the toppings and butter add to the total. The result tastes different from potato, and that is fine.

What about bread and pizza?

Bread is the swap people miss most. White bread has about 55 grams of carbohydrate per 100 grams once toasted, so even a thin slice adds up quickly. Low-carb breads are on the market and some cooks bake with almond flour or other non-wheat flours, but labels vary, so check the carbohydrate and fiber counts per serving. For pizza, large portobello mushroom caps, low-carb tortillas or a crustless “pizza casserole” with the same toppings are simple ways to keep the flavor.

Are sugar substitutes a good idea?

Be cautious. Many low-carb recipes rely on artificial sweeteners, and some dieters report that sweet tastes make them want even more sweet food. The World Health Organization advises against using non-sugar sweeteners to control body weight. Its review found that their use does not give a long-term benefit in reducing body fat in adults or children, and that long-term use may be linked with a higher risk of type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease and death in adults. The advice from WHO is to look for other ways to reduce free sugars, such as eating fruit or unsweetened foods and drinks. WHO calls this a conditional recommendation, because the link between sweeteners and disease may be confounded by the characteristics of the people studied, but it is a good reason not to build your diet around sweeteners. See our post on carbohydrate cravings and the Atkins diet and Atkins and sugar cravings.

Is it a good idea to go low-carb?

A low-carb plan is not right for everyone. If you have diabetes, kidney disease or are pregnant, or if you take medicine for blood sugar or blood pressure, speak to your doctor before cutting carbohydrates sharply. For an overview of how the plan works, read Atkins diet basics. For meal ideas, see planning for Atkins. You can read more about the evidence on non-sugar sweeteners in the WHO news release.

Atkins and Ketosis: What Ketosis Is and What Ketone Strips Can Tell You

by on Saturday, January 2nd, 2010

Atkins and ketosis

What is ketosis?

The core idea of the Atkins diet is that a state called ketosis makes your body burn its fat stores for energy. Many people, even some who follow low-carbohydrate diets, are not sure what ketosis is or why it works, so here is a plain explanation.

Your body’s preferred fuel is glucose, which comes from carbohydrates. When you eat very little carbohydrate, your blood sugar and insulin levels fall, and the liver begins to break down fat into fatty acids and then into substances called ketones. Ketones are a normal fuel that many tissues, including the brain, can use. When your body is making ketones this way, it is in ketosis. It is also a normal state that occurs during fasting.

How is it different from simply cutting calories?

Dr. Atkins argued that most diets just reduce calories and cause you to lose muscle as well as fat, which slows your metabolism, while a low-carbohydrate diet burns mainly fat. It is true that weight loss by any method can include some loss of muscle, and that is a good reason to eat enough protein and to keep up strength exercise. But studies have not shown that ketosis protects muscle or speeds up metabolism. A large analysis of 48 trials found that low-carbohydrate and low-fat diets led to very similar weight loss after 12 months, about 7 kilograms (roughly 16 pounds) each. The best diet is the one you can stick to.

Is ketosis dangerous?

A common mistake is to think that being in ketosis is dangerous. For most healthy people it is a normal, natural state, and the human body creates ketones to use as fuel when glucose is scarce. It should not be confused with diabetic ketoacidosis, a dangerous emergency in which a person who lacks insulin, usually someone with type 1 diabetes, has very high ketones and high blood sugar. If you have diabetes, kidney or liver disease, or are pregnant or breast-feeding, talk to your doctor before you try a low-carbohydrate diet.

In the first days some people feel tired, get headaches, constipation or bad breath. These effects usually pass, and drinking enough water helps.

How do ketone strips work?

The Atkins books suggest ketone test strips to confirm that you are in ketosis. You hold the strip in your urine stream or dip it in a sample. A chemically treated pad changes color if ketones are present, from pink to purple, and you compare it with the color scale on the bottle. The strips are sold in pharmacies, often near diabetic supplies, and you do not need a prescription. Once you open a bottle they have a limited shelf life, often around six months, so check the label and write the opening date on the box.

How do you read the results?

The strips tell you whether you are making ketones, but they are only a rough guide. If you are in Induction and do not see purple, do not worry. Some people never show more than traces of ketones, or only a color just above the minimum line. You can judge your progress by your weight, your waist and how you feel. If you exercised a few hours before testing, you may not see purple either.

Some dieters wrongly think that the darkest color means they are losing fat faster. In fact, a very dark color mostly means that your urine is concentrated, which can be a sign that you are dehydrated, so drink some water. Ketones also come from fat in your bloodstream, whether you ate it or burned it. If you eat a meal high in fat and then test right away, you will probably see a dark result. Use the strips as a guide and do not get hung up on the color.

How can vegetarians do it?

Vegetarians can follow a low-carbohydrate plan with eggs, cheese, tofu, tempeh, nuts, seeds, avocado, olive oil and non-starchy vegetables, though it takes planning. Our posts on the basics of the Atkins diet, the Atkins induction rules and carbohydrate cravings on Atkins explain how the early weeks work. If you want to read more about ketosis, the Cleveland Clinic has a clear guide.

Atkins Lifetime Maintenance: How to Keep the Weight Off for Good

by on Tuesday, November 24th, 2009

Losing weight is only half of the job. Keeping it off is the part many people find harder, and it is the purpose of the last phase of the Atkins plan. The old version of this post described Lifetime Maintenance, but much of it was unreadable. This rewrite covers the same ground in plain English and checks the advice against Atkins guidance and the best study of people who have kept weight off.

What is Lifetime Maintenance?

According to Atkins, you reach this phase once you have held your goal weight for a month. By then you should know your personal carb tolerance, which Atkins defines as the number of grams of net carbs you can eat while neither gaining nor losing weight. Atkins says most people find theirs between 40 and 120 grams of net carbs a day, depending on metabolism, age, gender and activity level, and that people who exercise regularly will probably have a higher tolerance. The old post said the same thing in different words: you use the carb count you learned in the earlier phases as a daily guide.

How can you tell if the plan is working?

The old post recommended choosing a maintenance range, for example 160 to 170 pounds if your goal was 165, and never letting your weight drift more than three to five pounds in either direction. Weighing yourself once a week was also recommended. This is practical advice, not an Atkins rule, but it fits what researchers have found. Members of the National Weight Control Registry, a group of people who have kept off at least 30 pounds for a year or more, mostly report weighing themselves regularly. Your weight can swing by a couple of pounds from day to day. The old post blamed hormones, and I could not confirm that, so the safest approach is to look at the trend over several weeks.

What do people who keep weight off actually do?

The registry paper by Hill and colleagues (2005) describes more than 4,800 participants who had, on average, lost over 70 pounds and kept it off for almost six years. Their common habits were a low-calorie, low-fat diet, eating breakfast almost every day (nearly 80 percent), about an hour a day of physical activity (walking was the most common), and regular weighing, with most weighing daily. People who kept a consistent diet on weekdays, weekends and holidays were best able to maintain their loss. It is worth noting that very few registry members followed low-carb diets, so the findings are not specific to Atkins, and the registry is not a random sample, so it cannot tell us how common success is. Even so, the habits are useful to copy. Read the paper: the National Weight Control Registry overview.

What should you do if the scale creeps up?

Atkins advises that if you gain weight or your cravings come back, you can regain control by dropping your carb intake by 10 to 20 grams. The old post suggested a similar approach: if you gain more than five pounds, buckle down and cut back. Act early. A few pounds are far easier to lose than 20, and regular weighing helps you catch the change quickly. Our post on overcoming plateaus on the Atkins diet shows how to adjust, and Atkins and sugar cravings helps if sweets are the trigger.

How do you deal with real life?

The old post said that keeping weight off means dealing with stress eating, emotional eating, holidays and restaurants. It is true that these situations are where most people slip. Plan ahead: look at a menu before you go, decide what you will order, and have a plan for the holidays. The old post also suggested donating your larger clothes and writing a list of the benefits of your new size. Those are personal motivation tricks, not research-backed methods, but they work for some people. If cost is a worry on a long-term low-carb plan, see eating low-carb on a budget.

What is the main message?

Maintenance is a long game. Keep exercising, check your weight regularly, and adjust carbs when needed. If you have a medical condition such as diabetes, kidney disease or heart disease, ask your doctor to review your plan regularly, since your medication and needs can change as your weight does. For the earlier steps in the plan, see Atkins diet basics.