Archive for the ‘Atkins’ Category

Low-Carb Snack Ideas for Atkins and Other Low-Carb Plans, With Real Carb Counts

by on Thursday, October 8th, 2009

Many of us snack through the day, and most packaged snack foods are full of refined carbohydrate. That makes snacking a challenge on the Atkins plan or any other low-carb way of eating. The good news is that plenty of simple foods are low in carbohydrates. This guide gives real numbers from the USDA FoodData Central database, so you can plan snacks with confidence.

Why do snacks cause trouble on a low-carb plan?

Chips, crackers, cookies and sweets are made mostly of flour and sugar. The old post also pointed out that some snack foods contain trans fats. The FDA says that most of the trans fat in food used to come from partially hydrogenated oils, and that eating trans fat raises LDL (“bad”) cholesterol. The FDA has taken major steps to remove these oils from the food supply, but trans fat also occurs naturally in small amounts in milk, butter, cheese and meat from ruminant animals. Check labels, because a product that lists “0 g trans fat” may still contain less than half a gram per serving. Read more on the FDA page about trans fat.

Which snacks are low in carbohydrate?

These are approximate net carbs (total carbohydrate minus fiber), worked out from USDA FoodData Central values. One large hard-boiled egg: about 0.6 g. One ounce (28 g) of part-skim mozzarella: about 0.8 g. One ounce of cheddar: about 0.7 g. One ounce of cream cheese: about 1.6 g. One ounce of raw almonds: about 2.6 g. One ounce of walnuts: about 2.0 g. A medium stalk of celery: about 0.5 g. About 100 g (3.5 ounces) of California avocado: about 1.8 g. Plain pork rinds contain no carbohydrate. Portion sizes matter: nuts and cheese are high in calories, so a handful is a snack, and a bag is a meal.

What should you watch out for?

Be careful with jerky and other cured meats. USDA data for one chopped and formed beef jerky shows about 11 g of carbohydrate per 100 g, which is around 3 g in a one-ounce portion, and flavored products can have more, so read the label. Peanut butter is a legume product, and USDA data for smooth peanut butter without salt shows about 5.5 g of net carbs in two tablespoons (32 g), so it adds up fast. Atkins does not allow legumes in the first phase. The old post suggested spreading peanut butter or cream cheese on celery. Cream cheese is the lower-carb choice for Induction.

What about fruit and the later phases?

Atkins says that most fruit is not allowed during Induction, and that berries and other fruit come back in later phases. Raw raspberries are one of the lower-carb fruits, with about 3.4 g net carbs in half a cup (62 g), but they still count toward your daily limit. Olives are another choice: about 4.4 g net carbs per 100 g for canned ripe olives, and Atkins counts 10 black olives toward the daily allowance in Induction. See our posts on low-carb swaps and Atkins and sugar cravings for more ideas.

How do you prepare?

Clear the junk food out of the house if you can, and keep prepared snacks where you can reach them: boiled eggs, cheese portions, cut celery and cucumber, a small container of nuts. Eating regularly can help you avoid getting too hungry, which is one reason why Atkins advises not going more than six waking hours without eating. For help with plateaus, see overcoming plateaus on the Atkins diet. You can look up almost any food yourself on USDA FoodData Central.

Common Mistakes Atkins Dieters Make (and How to Avoid Them)

by on Thursday, June 4th, 2009

Common mistakes of Atkins dieters

The Atkins diet is a low-carbohydrate plan, and the rules look simple. The books lay them out clearly, but some misunderstandings come up again and again, and they can make a big difference to how much weight you lose. If the diet is not working for you, or if you suddenly gain weight after weeks of success, check whether you are making any of these mistakes.

Are you expecting too much, too fast?

Be patient. The first phase, called Induction, limits you to about 20 grams of net carbohydrates a day. Some people lose several pounds in the first week, but much of that is water. When you move to the ongoing weight loss phase and begin to add small amounts of carbohydrate back, weight loss often slows down. That is completely normal. Induction is not meant to carry you through the rest of the diet. Its purpose is to break your carbohydrate cravings and get you used to eating fewer sugary and starchy foods.

People also respond differently. Some lose weight in spurts and others lose it steadily. A plateau can last for a few weeks, and then you suddenly lose a few pounds in a few days. Health authorities suggest that a steady loss of about one to two pounds a week is more likely to stay off than a faster one.

What about caffeine and artificial sweeteners?

Older Atkins books told dieters to avoid caffeine and artificial sweeteners such as aspartame, which are found in diet sodas and sugar-free gelatin, on the theory that they might trigger sugar cravings. Some dieters go further and believe that a single serving can knock you out of ketosis. That is not correct, because drinks like these contain almost no carbohydrate. The evidence on cravings is mixed. If you notice that a diet soda or a strong coffee sets off cravings for sweet things, cut back on it. Watch out for sugar and milk added to coffee, which do count.

Are you eating too much cheese?

Cheese is on the list of allowed foods, but it has some carbohydrate, and it adds up. A sensible limit is about four ounces a day, and you should not rely on cheese for most of your protein. Eggs, tofu, tempeh, nuts and seeds are better choices for vegetarians, and meat or fish for those who eat them, because they contain few or no carbohydrates.

Are you skipping vegetables?

Your carbohydrate grams should come mainly from leafy greens and other non-starchy vegetables. They fill you up without spiking your blood sugar, and they supply fiber and nutrients that support both weight loss and general health. A typical suggestion is a few cups of salad vegetables and about a cup of cooked vegetables every day, picked from the acceptable foods list. If you cut out vegetables, you risk constipation and missing nutrients, which will not help you stay on the plan.

Are you eating regularly?

Do not let yourself go too long without food. When you go many hours between meals, your blood sugar can drop and leave you craving bread and sugar. Many Atkins dieters plan a small snack of protein and fat every few hours, such as a boiled egg, a handful of nuts or a piece of cheese. Skipping meals will not by itself shut down your metabolism, but long gaps do make it harder to stick to the plan.

Are you drinking enough water?

Water has benefits for everyone, not just people on Atkins. Sometimes thirst can feel like hunger, so staying hydrated can help you resist foods that you should not be eating. Water also helps prevent constipation, which can be a side effect of a low-carbohydrate diet. The traditional advice is about eight glasses a day, though your own needs vary with your size, activity and the weather.

Is Atkins right for you?

These everyday mistakes frustrate many people when there is no need to. If you are just starting, prepare for them. If you have been on the diet for a while, review your habits and make sure that you are following the program correctly. Low-carbohydrate diets can have side effects, and they are not suitable for everyone, so see your doctor first if you have diabetes, kidney disease or another health condition, or if you are pregnant. For more, read our posts on Atkins induction rules, whether Atkins is right for you, the pros and cons of the Atkins diet and how to deal with sugar cravings on Atkins.

Does Atkins Curb Your Appetite? Protein, Eggs, Fiber and Feeling Full

by on Thursday, May 28th, 2009

People who follow the Atkins plan often say they get less hungry between meals. The old version of this post explained that with a mix of facts and some very confident guesses, including that your stomach “creates a chemical response” because it believes it is full. Not all of that holds up. Here is what is known about appetite on a low-carb plan and what is not.

Does protein really make you feel fuller?

Generally, yes, though the effect is modest. Reviews of research on satiety, including one in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, find that higher-protein meals tend to increase fullness and reduce later eating more than carbohydrate or fat, but the effect depends on the amount, the food and the timing. Atkins meals are built around protein and fat, with carbs coming mostly from vegetables. The old post argued that a carb-heavy meal does not have staying power, and many people do notice that sweet, refined carbs leave them hungry again soon. That is a reasonable personal observation, but the explanation (blood sugar “highs and crashes”) is not proven in every case.

What does the egg study show?

The old post mentioned a study in which women who ate eggs for breakfast stayed fuller than women who ate bagels. The study is real, though the details were slightly off. In a 2005 trial reported in the Journal of the American College of Nutrition, 30 overweight or obese women ate either an egg breakfast or a bagel breakfast, with the same calories and the same weight of food. Each woman tried both, two weeks apart. After the egg breakfast the women felt fuller and ate less at lunch 3.5 hours later: about 2,406 kilojoules versus 3,091 kilojoules, and they also ate less over the rest of the day and the next 36 hours. The authors concluded that the possible role of a routine egg breakfast in weight loss “should be determined,” so it is a promising result, not proof. See the abstract: egg breakfast and satiety study.

What else is in an egg?

According to USDA data, a large egg has about 6 grams of protein and roughly 147 milligrams of choline, a nutrient used by the brain and nervous system. The old post said that you should eat the whole egg and not just the white, because the yolk has lutein, zeaxanthin and choline. It is right that the yolk contains these. Eggs also contain cholesterol, so if you have high cholesterol or diabetes, ask your doctor how many are right for you. Our post on what cholesterol is explains why this matters.

Do broccoli and cauliflower help with hunger?

They provide bulk and fiber for very few net carbs, which is why they are staples on the plan. Fiber can improve fullness, though research is mixed and it does not always reduce how much people eat. The old post made some stronger statements, such as that your stomach reduces your appetite when stretched “regardless of what is in your stomach” and that water and psyllium husk work the same way. I could not find reliable support for those, so I have removed them. A simpler message holds: vegetables add volume and nutrients to a meal.

What if you still feel hungry?

Cleveland Clinic notes that if you are not eating enough fat or protein on a low-carb plan, you may not feel full and the hunger will continue. Eating more often, and choosing a variety of allowed foods, may also help. Hunger that does not settle can be a sign that you are cutting calories too low, or that you are missing fiber. Our posts on Atkins and sugar cravings and carbohydrate cravings and the Atkins diet explain how to manage the other kind of hunger, the craving for sweet or starchy foods.

What is the bottom line?

A low-carb plan can help some people feel less hungry, and protein, eggs and vegetables are a good set of tools. But it is not a magic appetite switch, and the old claims that it “suppresses” appetite through special chemical effects are unproven. Focus on regular meals with protein and fiber, and see Atkins diet basics for the overall approach.

Atkins Criticism: What Critics Say and What the Research Shows

by on Monday, March 30th, 2009

The Atkins diet has always attracted strong opinions. The old version of this post defended it against its critics, using claims such as “thousands of testimonials” and “easy to follow for long periods.” Testimonials are not evidence, so this rewrite looks at the main criticisms one by one and checks each against research. The aim is not to attack or defend the diet, but to give you an accurate picture before you decide.

Is it too high in fat?

This is the oldest criticism. Atkins says its plan includes a balance of monounsaturated, polyunsaturated and saturated fats and that manufactured trans fats should be avoided. The old post emphasized olive oil and other helpful fats. Heart-health guidance is more cautious about saturated fat: MedlinePlus describes the Therapeutic Lifestyle Changes diet, which advises getting less than 7 percent of daily calories from saturated fat. A low-carb plan built on butter, cream and fatty meat would exceed that limit easily, so if you follow Atkins, it makes sense to choose fish, poultry, nuts, olive oil and vegetables for most of your fat and to ask your doctor about your cholesterol.

Does Atkins ignore exercise?

The old post replied that the Atkins books clearly spell out a need for exercise, and the Atkins site does say that being active is important. So this criticism is weaker than it is often made out to be. The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans say adults need 150 to 300 minutes of moderate activity a week whatever diet they follow, and our post on everyday activities that count as moderate exercise shows how to fit that in.

Is it hard to keep up for the long term?

Critics say it works for a while and is then hard to stay on. The old post said people who succeed with it find it easy. The research is mixed. In the 2018 DIETFITS trial of 609 adults, those on a healthy low-carb diet lost 6.0 kg after 12 months, compared with 5.3 kg on a healthy low-fat diet, and the 0.7 kg difference was not statistically significant. Both groups were coached for a year, and about one in five people did not finish the trial. Seen from this angle, the diet worked about as well as a good low-fat diet, no better and no worse. Whether you can sustain it depends on whether you like the foods. For people with type 2 diabetes, an American Diabetes Association consensus report found that the blood sugar benefits of very low-carb diets were clearer at 3 and 6 months than at 12 and 24 months.

What about the side effects?

The old post said constipation and bad breath are less common than critics claim and usually last only through the first phase, and that drinking more water helps. Part of that is right. Cleveland Clinic says that “keto flu” symptoms, which include irritability, nausea and constipation or diarrhea, can appear two to seven days after you reach ketosis and usually last one to two weeks, though they can last as long as a month. If the problem persists, speak to your doctor. Eating enough fiber from vegetables, nuts and seeds, and drinking plenty of fluids, often helps, and our guide to Atkins and intestinal problems has more tips.

Who should be careful?

Some people should not follow a very low-carb plan without medical supervision. The American Diabetes Association’s 2019 consensus report says more research is needed in people with chronic kidney disease, disordered eating patterns and women who are pregnant. Its Standards of Care add that low-carb plans are not recommended for women who are pregnant or lactating, people with or at risk for disordered eating, or people with kidney disease, and should be used with caution with a class of diabetes drugs called SGLT2 inhibitors because of the risk of ketoacidosis. If you take medicine for diabetes or blood pressure, the dose may need to change. Always check with your doctor first.

So who is Atkins right for?

The old post concluded that if you do not enjoy preparing and eating meat, Atkins is probably not for you. That overlooks the fact that vegetarian versions exist, but the point stands: the best diet is the one you can follow safely for a long time. Look beyond both the hype and the criticism. If you decide to try it, read the Atkins diet basics, avoid the common mistakes Atkins dieters make, and see the 2018 trial for yourself: DIETFITS trial.

Eating Low-Carb on a Budget: Practical Ways to Cut Costs Without Dropping the Plan

by on Tuesday, January 20th, 2009

Low-carb eating can be expensive when it leans on fresh meat, specialty products and recipes with long ingredient lists. It does not have to be. A few habits will lower the cost of a week of meals without changing what you eat. Here are the ones that work best.

Why does planning save money?

Recipes in diet books often call for pricey ingredients because they are meant to look impressive. You can follow a low-carb plan with simple meals such as eggs and vegetables, a roast chicken with salad, or a stir-fry made from what is in the freezer. Plan the week’s menu, write a shopping list and go after you have eaten, because shopping when you are hungry usually adds to the bill. If you are following a specific plan, our posts on planning for Atkins and Atkins diet basics explain what to include.

Is buying in bulk and freezing safe?

Yes, when you do it properly. The USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service says that food kept constantly at 0 °F stays safe, and that recommended storage times are for quality only. Uncooked ground meat keeps its best quality for 3 to 4 months and cooked meat for 2 to 3 months. Divide large packs into meal-sized portions in freezer bags, label them with the date, and thaw them in the refrigerator, in cold water or in the microwave, never on the counter. Freeze leftovers within 3 to 4 days. See the USDA guidance on freezing food.

Which protein foods are the best value?

Look beyond steak. Cuts that are often cheaper, such as chicken thighs, and cuts that cook well in a slow cooker, can give you protein for less. Eggs are a bargain: USDA data show that 100 grams of hard-boiled egg has about 12.6 grams of protein and about 1 gram of carbohydrate, and roasted chicken thigh meat has about 24.8 grams of protein and no carbohydrate. Tofu is another option. Keep an eye on legumes, which are inexpensive but contain carbohydrate: boiled lentils have about 19.5 grams per 100 grams and canned kidney beans about 21.5 grams, so they may only fit in small amounts, depending on the stage of your plan.

Can you save on vegetables?

Buy whole heads of lettuce rather than bagged salad, since you pay for the washing and chopping with bagged salad. Romaine has only about 3 grams of carbohydrate per 100 grams. Frozen vegetables are convenient and cheap, and the USDA notes that the freezing process itself does not destroy nutrients. Cauliflower, broccoli and spinach are good choices. A salad spinner keeps leaves crisp, so that less is thrown away.

Are low-carb products worth buying?

Usually not. Low-carb bars, breads and snacks tend to cost more than ordinary foods, and the label can hide extra carbohydrate. They also often use sweeteners, and the World Health Organization advises against relying on non-sugar sweeteners for weight control. Spend your money on real food instead. If you want to try a swap, cauliflower rice and zucchini noodles are simple and cheap. Check the nutrition facts panel, and look up foods in the USDA FoodData Central database when you are not sure.

What else helps?

Use sales: if chicken thighs are cheaper than breasts this week, swap them in, as long as the recipe stays within your plan. Cook once and eat twice, for example by roasting a large tray of vegetables and chicken. Keep a food list in your phone so that you can check an unfamiliar sale item. And remember that diets for weight loss work best when you can keep them up for a long time; a plan that you can afford is one you can follow. Our post on common mistakes Atkins dieters make lists the pitfalls to avoid.